{"schema_version":"1.0","country":"de","country_name":"Germany","topic":"electrical-substations","question":"Where can I get the locations of electrical substations in Germany (transmission and distribution), with voltage level and operator?","territory":"de","territory_level":"country","parent_url":null,"published_on":"2026-11-19","research_reviewed_on":"2026-11-15","access_checked_on":null,"answer":{"official_data":"partial","non_official_data":"partial","summary":"OSM is the broadest tested national source for transmission and distribution locations, but only 16.25% of mapped substations have voltage and 33.49% have operator. Official national Basis-DLM geometry exists behind a paid licence, with free regional services, but its inclusion rule misses much distribution and it lacks these electrical attributes. JAO supplies official selected transmission names, voltage and asset owners; VDE and TSO maps supply geometry. No tested source answers the whole question completely.","main_caveats":["Basis-DLM is a national official dataset, not a complete all-voltage registry: its substation land-use class follows recorded overhead lines and has no voltage/operator fields.","OSM counts are mapped objects, not a completeness estimate: 90,928/108,567 lack voltage and 72,208 lack operator; nodes, areas and multi-site relations need careful interpretation.","VDE is an association publication, not official operator data; it mixes existing and planned sites, has no voltage column and leaves Eigentum blank on 473/557 points.","JAO workbook has no coordinates. Its HTML substation markers are unlabelled; a transformer or line owner is not automatically the operator of every asset at a co-located station.","The research exceeded the 80-opening limit (117 reconstructed requests); remaining leads are explicitly unchecked. Distribution completeness and full official attribute coverage remain unresolved."],"confidence":"medium","confidence_reason":"Live data tests and document examples support the partial answer. The opening limit was exceeded before it was noticed; national electrical-attribute completeness and several pending leads were not resolved.","attributes":[{"attribute":"location","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s001"],"note":"Coverage combines distinct components of the question; see the original detailed evidence and its geographic and technical limits.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"The original rows have different scopes. Their combination has not been established as complete; original rows are retained in internal curation."},{"attribute":"voltage","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s004","s002"],"note":"Coverage combines distinct components of the question; see the original detailed evidence and its geographic and technical limits.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"The original rows have different scopes. Their combination has not been established as complete; original rows are retained in internal curation."},{"attribute":"operator","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s004","s001"],"note":"Coverage combines distinct components of the question; see the original detailed evidence and its geographic and technical limits.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"The original rows have different scopes. Their combination has not been established as complete; original rows are retained in internal curation."}]},"sources":[{"source_id":"s001","name":"OpenStreetMap substations: Germany extract, Taginfo and tested Overpass query","publisher":"OpenStreetMap contributors; Geofabrik; Overpass Europe","official":false,"landing_url":"https://download.geofabrik.de/europe/germany.html","data_url":"https://ovp.dresel.systems/api/interpreter","access":"api","format":"Overpass JSON / OSM PBF","license":"ODbL-1.0","language":"de/en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"community","adds":"Broad national geometry including transmission and distribution, with optional voltage/operator tags.","first_seen_pass":null,"rank":1,"summary":"OpenStreetMap substations: Germany extract, Taginfo and tested Overpass query","coverage_note":"Germany; regional API sample in central Berlin","data_date":"Taginfo country statistics: 2026-11-13T21:22:16Z; regional Overpass response: 2026-11-13T21:22:20Z.","caveats":["Consult the main caveats and the complete reading traps and access evidence in the detail."],"coverage":{"geographic":"Germany; regional API sample in central Berlin"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Voltage values are in volts without a unit or thousands delimiter; the separate key_fields/reading_traps describe geometry units.","quote":"Values should be entered in volts without the unit or thousand delimiter.","url":"https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:voltage","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"The documented tag denotes a facility controlling electricity flow; the tested query selects power=substation objects.","quote":"A facility which controls the flow of electricity","url":"https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:power%3Dsubstation","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Taginfo country statistics: 2026-11-13T21:22:16Z; regional Overpass response: 2026-11-13T21:22:20Z.","quote":"\"data_until\":\"2026-11-13T21:22:16Z\"","url":"https://taginfo.geofabrik.de/europe:germany/api/4/tag/overview?key=power&value=substation","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Upstream edits are continuous. The extract page exposes dated daily snapshots; no single site-survey date applies.","quote":"germany-261113.osm.pbf","url":"https://download.geofabrik.de/europe/germany.html","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Pole-mounted transformers are excluded from the documented power=substation tag.","quote":"A pole-mounted transformer should not be tagged as a substation.","url":"https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:power%3Dsubstation","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"type,id","meaning":"Together form an object identifier; do not use id alone."},{"field":"lat,lon / center","meaning":"Nodes have coordinates; out center returns an area bounding-box centre, not a surveyed equipment position."},{"field":"tags.substation","meaning":"Role when present; absence is not evidence of distribution/transmission tier."},{"field":"tags.voltage","meaning":"Semicolon separated volts, optional."},{"field":"tags.operator","meaning":"Optional operator name; distinct from owner."},{"field":"tags.name, tags.ref","meaning":"Optional names/local references."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sS --max-time 45 'https://ovp.dresel.systems/api/interpreter' --data-urlencode 'data=[out:json][timeout:25];nwr[\"power\"=\"substation\"](52.45,13.25,52.58,13.60);out center 3;'\nCount request also executed: data=[out:json][timeout:25];nwr[\"power\"=\"substation\"](52.45,13.25,52.58,13.60);out count;","example_result":"[{\"type\": \"node\", \"id\": 266183963, \"lat\": 52.5274577, \"lon\": 13.3988686, \"tags\": {\"operator\": \"Stromnetz Berlin\", \"operator:wikidata\": \"Q110255475\", \"power\": \"substation\", \"ref\": \"20927\", \"source\": \"survey\"}}, {\"type\": \"node\", \"id\": 280256259, \"lat\": 52.5586504, \"lon\": 13.343468, \"tags\": {\"operator\": \"Stromnetz Berlin\", \"operator:wikidata\": \"Q110255475\", \"power\": \"substation\", \"ref\": \"241\", \"source\": \"survey\", \"substation\": \"minor_distribution\"}}]","steps":["The exact Berlin bounding-box query returned 1,193 objects (612 nodes, 580 ways, 1 relation); the sample returned three nodes.","For a national extraction the Geofabrik page exposes germany-latest.osm.pbf (4.5 GB). That bulk file was not downloaded because of the 100 MB trial limit. Country statistics were tested separately with Taginfo.","Retain object type, id, geometry and source timestamp. Interpret voltage as V and preserve multiple levels. Empty role/operator/voltage tags remain unknown.","Separate physical sites from several voltage buses and preserve lifecycle/type qualifiers; no completeness or operating-status filter was established for the whole country."],"reading_traps":["108,567 country objects: 31,725 nodes, 76,802 ways and 40 relations. Of these 17,639 have voltage and 36,359 operator; 90,928 and 72,208 respectively lack these tags.","The current tested combinations endpoint gives 3,695 exact substation=distribution matches; the first card incorrectly used 4,832 (the all-tag value total, not its intersection with power=substation).","Geofabrik country extracts and their tag statistics are extraction regions; boundary objects and multipart geometry need a proper boundary check. Only three Berlin sample points were checked geographically and all fit the stated box.","A national PBF was not tested. The first card’s general claim that the main Overpass endpoint rejects automatic clients was not independently retested and is not inherited.","Geometry tagged exact means the mapped feature footprint, with no guaranteed survey accuracy; node/area duplicates or split sites are possible."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/json","size_bytes":998,"records_total":108567,"records_for_country":108567,"problems":["Voltage and operator are optional and incomplete. Sample endpoint returned three Berlin nodes; national total is a separate tested Taginfo count, not an Overpass national query."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Country total and element types were returned by Taginfo.","url":"https://taginfo.geofabrik.de/europe:germany/api/4/tag/overview?key=power&value=substation","quote":"\"count\":108567"},{"claim":"Regional combinations, not all objects carrying the other tag, determine attribute coverage.","url":"https://taginfo.geofabrik.de/europe:germany/api/4/tag/combinations?key=power&value=substation&filter=all&sortname=together_count&sortorder=desc&page=1&rp=100","quote":"\"other_key\":\"voltage\",\"other_value\":\"\",\"together_count\":17639"},{"claim":"Current extract date and large file size.","url":"https://download.geofabrik.de/europe/germany.html","quote":"contains all OSM data up to 2026-11-13T21:22:20Z. File size: 4.5 GB."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s002","name":"Official topographic substation geometry: nationwide Basis-DLM and regional/local services","publisher":"BKG / Länder surveying administrations; Geobasis NRW; WFBB Brandenburg; Landkreis Diepholz","official":true,"landing_url":"https://gdz.bkg.bund.de/index.php/default/digitale-geodaten/digitale-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis-landschaftsmodell.html","data_url":null,"access":"paid","format":"National SHP/NAS; NRW WFS GML; Brandenburg WFS GeoJSON; Diepholz ArcGIS JSON","license":"National: paid proprietary licence; NRW: dl-de/zero-2-0; Brandenburg and Diepholz: dl-de/by-2-0","language":"de","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"national_government","adds":"A national official geometry source and demonstrated structured distribution geometry, missing from the first card’s documents-only description.","first_seen_pass":null,"rank":2,"summary":"Official topographic substation geometry: nationwide Basis-DLM and regional/local services","coverage_note":"National paid dataset plus free NRW, Brandenburg and Diepholz examples","data_date":"National BKG product2026-10 uses updates from April to June2026. Member-specific dates are recorded in reading_traps and tests.","caveats":["Consult the main caveats and the complete reading traps and access evidence in the detail."],"coverage":{"geographic":"National paid dataset plus free NRW, Brandenburg and Diepholz examples"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"The topographic function is Umspannstation; actual schema code2540 is demonstrated in the tested regional responses.","quote":"Umspannstation","url":"https://sg.geodatenzentrum.de/web_public/gdz/dokumentation/deu/ok_basis-dlm_712.pdf","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Basis-DLM records stations associated with recorded overhead lines, not every underground MV/LV station.","quote":"FKT 2540 alle Umspannstationen im Netz der erfassten Freileitungen","url":"https://sg.geodatenzentrum.de/web_public/gdz/dokumentation/deu/ok_basis-dlm_712.pdf","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"National BKG product2026-10 uses updates from April to June2026. Member-specific dates are recorded in reading_traps and tests.","quote":"Produktstand 2026-10: Datenaktualisierung Stand April bis Juni 2026","url":"https://gdz.bkg.bund.de/index.php/default/digitale-geodaten/digitale-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis-landschaftsmodell.html","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"BKG general update three years, selected objects 3–12 months; NRW online service monthly.","quote":"Aktualisierung der Onlinedatenbestände: monatlich","url":"https://www.bezreg-koeln.nrw.de/geobasis-nrw/produkte-und-dienste/landschaftsmodelle/aktuelle-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Basis-DLM does not guarantee substations away from the recorded overhead-line network; no all-voltage distribution completeness follows from this class.","quote":"FKT 2540 alle Umspannstationen im Netz der erfassten Freileitungen","url":"https://sg.geodatenzentrum.de/web_public/gdz/dokumentation/deu/ok_basis-dlm_712.pdf","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"adv:funktion / FKT","meaning":"2540 means substation land-use area; filter required in general land-use layers."},{"field":"gml:id / OBJID","meaning":"Stable topographic object identifier, not an electrical asset ID."},{"field":"adv:position / geometry","meaning":"Polygon geometry; CRS and axis order must be retained."},{"field":"NAM / adv:name","meaning":"Optional geographic name, not always present."},{"field":"Diepholz layer 11 / layer 12","meaning":"The layer name supplies 110 kV / 380 kV; no numeric voltage field."},{"field":"Diepholz Name, Standort, PLZ, Erf_Datum","meaning":"Station name, locality, postcode and recording date; Erfasser is the data editor, not network operator."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sSL --max-time 60 --max-filesize 100000000 'https://www.wfs.nrw.de/geobasis/wfs_nw_atkis-basis-dlm_aaa-modell-basiert' --get --data-urlencode 'service=WFS' --data-urlencode 'version=2.0.0' --data-urlencode 'request=GetFeature' --data-urlencode 'typeNames=adv:AX_IndustrieUndGewerbeflaeche' --data-urlencode 'srsName=urn:ogc:def:crs:EPSG::4258' --data-urlencode 'FILTER=<fes:Filter xmlns:fes=\"http://www.opengis.net/fes/2.0\" xmlns:adv=\"http://www.adv-online.de/namespaces/adv/gid/7.1\"><fes:PropertyIsEqualTo><fes:ValueReference>adv:funktion</fes:ValueReference><fes:Literal>2540</fes:Literal></fes:PropertyIsEqualTo></fes:Filter>'\nCount executed with the same FILTER and resultType=hits, without srsName.\nOther tested requests: https://geo.diepholz.de/arcgis/rest/services/Ver_und_Entsorgung/MapServer/11/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=*&outSR=4326&f=json\nhttps://geo.diepholz.de/arcgis/rest/services/Ver_und_Entsorgung/MapServer/11/query?where=1%3D1&returnCountOnly=true&f=json\nhttps://geo.diepholz.de/arcgis/rest/services/Ver_und_Entsorgung/MapServer/12/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=*&outSR=4326&f=json\nhttps://energieportal-brandenburg.de/geoserver/bepo/ows/?service=WFS&version=2.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=bepo:atkis_elektro&CQL_FILTER=FKT%3D%272540%27&count=3&outputFormat=application%2Fjson&srsName=EPSG:4326\nhttps://energieportal-brandenburg.de/geoserver/bepo/ows/?service=WFS&version=2.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=bepo:atkis_elektro&CQL_FILTER=FKT%3D%272540%27&resultType=hits","example_result":"NRW: numberReturned=858; first gml:id DENWAT0119X00068, funktion=2540, first vertex [51.9931001640809, 8.62961550259811] in EPSG:4258 axis order. Diepholz: Name=Umspannwerk Lemförde, Standort=Lemförde, x=8.3726564965213, y=52.47450309142273. Brandenburg: atkis_elektro.1, FKT=2540, OBJID=DEBBAT550001uA0B, first vertex [14.0087,52.786].","steps":["National data access is paid/licensed and was not tested; the documented Shape mapping is SIE02_F, OBJART=41002, FKT=2540. These field names come from the opened official Shape specification, not a national content download.","NRW WFS requires a declared adv namespace in the XML filter. A CQL_FILTER trial was silently ignored (39,919 all industrial areas); the proper FES filter counted 858 substation polygons and the full response returned all 858.","The NRW sample is GML EPSG:4258 with latitude–longitude order; Brandenburg GeoJSON requested EPSG:4326 returns longitude–latitude. Do not swap them silently.","Brandenburg atkis_elektro contains other functions; restrict FKT=2540. Only this filtered class is counted as substations. The generic alkis_elektro electricity-building layer is not a verified substation inventory.","Diepholz layer11 and layer12 are separate voltage classes; the tested full queries returned 12 and 2 features. The API query with outSR=4326 provides x=longitude,y=latitude.","Preserve topographic inclusion scope and reference date; missing voltage/operator remain unknown."],"reading_traps":["National Basis-DLM is real and includes substations, but the full paid data were not downloaded; national counts and national coordinate quality were not measured.","The official national documentation says ±15 m for objects other than transport/water; the first card’s blanket ±3 m for all substation topography was too strong.","All 858 NRW polygons’ vertices fit lat 50.3726–52.4693, lon 5.9684–9.3934 (0 outside broad NRW envelope). This is a plausibility test, not an administrative-boundary audit.","All 14 Diepholz points fit the catalogue region lon7.74–9.6,lat52.37–53.11; the three Brandenburg polygons fit the state map envelope. These tests do not prove national completeness.","Brandenburg page attribution dates the topography 2020-04-20; the tested atkis_elektro sample is MODELLART=DLM50 despite the page’s ALKIS wording.","The older DKAN 110kV table is dated 2021-11-30, omits names in its displayed rows and differs from the current ArcGIS positions; it must not be silently merged.","No operator column exists in the tested regional geometry. Erfasser=Blömer in Diepholz identifies the recorder."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/gml+xml","size_bytes":1146143,"records_total":858,"records_for_country":858,"problems":["The main national paid dataset was only inspected through product metadata and specifications, not acquired. Member counts are separate: NRW 858 polygons; Brandenburg 348 filtered polygons (sample3); Diepholz12+2 points."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"National access is licensed, not an unrestricted direct download.","url":"https://gdz.bkg.bund.de/index.php/default/digitale-geodaten/digitale-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis-landschaftsmodell.html","quote":"Den Zugang erhalten Sie nach Abschluss einer Lizenzvereinbarung."},{"claim":"The national object catalogue includes a substation land-use function.","url":"https://sg.geodatenzentrum.de/web_public/gdz/dokumentation/deu/ok_basis-dlm_712.pdf","quote":"Umspannstation"},{"claim":"NRW exposes the dataset through a WFS and whole-state download.","url":"https://www.bezreg-koeln.nrw.de/geobasis-nrw/produkte-und-dienste/landschaftsmodelle/aktuelle-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis","quote":"Die Daten des Basis-DLM werden sowohl über Webdienst (WFS) als auch auf OpenGeodata.NRW für ganz Nordrhein-Westfalen paketiert zum Download bereitgestellt."},{"claim":"Brandenburg map credits cadastral/topographic origins.","url":"https://energieportal-brandenburg.de/cms/inhalte/daten/karten/energieinfrastruktur","quote":"Darstellung der Umspannwerke (Gebäude zur Elektrizitätsversorgung, Umformer, Fläche Umspannwerk) und Hochspannungsanlagen, abgeleitet aus ALKIS GeoBasis-DE/LGB."},{"claim":"Diepholz official resource scope.","url":"https://daten.diepholz.de/datensatz/umspannwerke-110kv","quote":"Standorte Umspannwerke 110kV im Landkreis Diepholz"}],"members":[{"name":"BKG nationwide Basis-DLM","landing_url":"https://gdz.bkg.bund.de/index.php/default/digitale-geodaten/digitale-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis-landschaftsmodell.html","data_url":null,"access":"paid","tested":false,"data_found":null,"note":"National full data not downloaded or purchased. Product metadata and object catalogue opened; access follows licence agreement. The national package is approximately 7 GB SHP / 9 GB NAS."},{"name":"Geobasis NRW Basis-DLM WFS","landing_url":"https://www.bezreg-koeln.nrw.de/geobasis-nrw/produkte-und-dienste/landschaftsmodelle/aktuelle-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis","data_url":"https://www.wfs.nrw.de/geobasis/wfs_nw_atkis-basis-dlm_aaa-modell-basiert","access":"api","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"858 FKT2540 polygons returned. No voltage/operator fields; all vertices inside a broad NRW envelope. GML EPSG:4258 returns latitude then longitude."},{"name":"Brandenburg Energieportal topography","landing_url":"https://energieportal-brandenburg.de/cms/inhalte/daten/karten/energieinfrastruktur","data_url":"https://energieportal-brandenburg.de/geoserver/bepo/ows/","access":"api","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"348 FKT2540 DLM50 polygons counted; three returned. Page’s Umformung WMS is a group, not a WFS feature type. Underlying atkis_elektro also contains power plants; alkis_elektro includes generic electricity buildings."},{"name":"Landkreis Diepholz current ArcGIS","landing_url":"https://daten.diepholz.de/datensatz/umspannwerke-110kv","data_url":"https://geo.diepholz.de/arcgis/rest/services/Ver_und_Entsorgung/MapServer","access":"api","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"12 points in 110kV layer11 and two in 380kV layer12. No operator column. Legacy DKAN table is older and coordinates differ; current ArcGIS was used for examples."}],"members_summary":{"total":null,"listed":4,"tested":3,"data_found":0,"scope_note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null},"member_scope":{"total":null,"note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null}},{"source_id":"s003","name":"VDE FNN Deutsches Höchstspannungsnetz: Umspannwerke layer","publisher":"Forum Netztechnik/Netzbetrieb im VDE (VDE FNN)","official":false,"landing_url":"https://www.vde.com/de/fnn/dokumente/karte-deutsches-hoechstspannungsnetz","data_url":"https://services1.arcgis.com/LVZ4P2ZNVc4ceCSD/arcgis/rest/services/Umspannwerke/FeatureServer/0","access":"api","format":"ArcGIS REST JSON","license":"Copyright VDE FNN; attribution and publication notification requested; no open data licence stated","language":"de","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"community","adds":"Consolidated transmission station geometry, names and existing/planned categories across all four TSO areas.","first_seen_pass":null,"rank":3,"summary":"VDE FNN Deutsches Höchstspannungsnetz: Umspannwerke layer","coverage_note":"Germany extra-high-voltage system plus cross-border and offshore features","data_date":"Map print edition 01/2026; live layer dataLastEditDate=1761130912001 (2025-10-22), not independently a site-operating date.","caveats":["Consult the main caveats and the complete reading traps and access evidence in the detail."],"coverage":{"geographic":"Germany extra-high-voltage system plus cross-border and offshore features"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Point representing a station/converter, not one voltage bus.","quote":"\"geometryType\" : \"esriGeometryPoint\"","url":"https://services1.arcgis.com/LVZ4P2ZNVc4ceCSD/arcgis/rest/services/Umspannwerke/FeatureServer/0?f=pjson","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"The interactive transmission map shows lines, substations, power stations and peripherals; the tested point layer includes existing and planned categories.","quote":"Leitungen, Umspannwerke, Kraftwerke und Peripherie","url":"https://www.vde.com/de/fnn/dokumente/karte-deutsches-hoechstspannungsnetz","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Map print edition 01/2026; live layer dataLastEditDate=1761130912001 (2025-10-22), not independently a site-operating date.","quote":"\"dataLastEditDate\" : 1761130912001","url":"https://services1.arcgis.com/LVZ4P2ZNVc4ceCSD/arcgis/rest/services/Umspannwerke/FeatureServer/0?f=pjson","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"The stated online map update interval is annual.","quote":"jährlich","url":"https://www.vde.com/de/fnn/dokumente/karte-deutsches-hoechstspannungsnetz","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Its stated transmission scope is380kV and220kV; it is not a distribution source. The missing station-voltage attribute is a separate schema-test finding.","quote":"380 und 220 Kilovolt","url":"https://www.vde.com/de/fnn/dokumente/karte-deutsches-hoechstspannungsnetz","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"Name","meaning":"Station name, missing7/557."},{"field":"Eigentum","meaning":"Owner label, missing473/557; not uniformly a confirmed operator."},{"field":"Status","meaning":"Missing478/557."},{"field":"usw_visu","meaning":"More populated category combining station type and existing/planned state."},{"field":"geometry.x, geometry.y","meaning":"Longitude/latitude when outSR=4326."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"https://services1.arcgis.com/LVZ4P2ZNVc4ceCSD/arcgis/rest/services/Umspannwerke/FeatureServer/0/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=*&outSR=4326&f=json\nCount also executed: https://services1.arcgis.com/LVZ4P2ZNVc4ceCSD/arcgis/rest/services/Umspannwerke/FeatureServer/0/query?where=1%3D1&returnCountOnly=true&f=json","example_result":"[{\"attributes\": {\"OBJECTID\": 1, \"fid_1\": 1, \"Name\": \"Altdöbern\", \"Eigentum\": \"50HzT\", \"Kurzbez\": \"ADB\", \"Ort\": \" \", \"PLZ\": \" \", \"Status\": \"in Betrieb\", \"Strasse\": \" \", \"Hausnummer\": \" \", \"Kategorie\": \"Umspannwerk\", \"Anschluss\": \" \", \"GlobalID\": \"f396a9c3-fba9-4200-b4a1-5bb270e4037a\", \"usw_visu\": \"Trafostation | bestehend\", \"U_TECHPLAT\": null, \"U_BEZ_TECH\": null, \"KUERZEL\": null}, \"geometry\": {\"x\": 14.003396600102779, \"y\": 51.64073189891416}}, {\"attributes\": {\"OBJECTID\": 2, \"fid_1\": 2, \"Name\": \"Teufelsbruch\", \"Eigentum\": \"50HzT\", \"Kurzbez\": \"TB\", \"Ort\": \"Berlin\", \"PLZ\": \"13587\", \"Status\": \"in Betrieb\", \"Strasse\": \"Niederneuendorfer Allee\", \"Hausnummer\": \"60\", \"Kategorie\": \"Umspannwerk\", \"Anschluss\": \" \", \"GlobalID\": \"b98cc526-a255-4c51-a1e4-8ec23d0d41a2\", \"usw_visu\": \"Trafostation | bestehend\", \"U_TECHPLAT\": null, \"U_BEZ_TECH\": null, \"KUERZEL\": null}, \"geometry\": {\"x\": 13.211599001335392, \"y\": 52.58076499911927}}]","steps":["The tested full query returned557 features; the independent count also returned557.","Use outSR=4326 and retain geometry, Name, Eigentum and usw_visu. The tested response fitted in one request.","Read existing/planned state from usw_visu where available. Missing values remain unknown; no voltage-from-line inference was performed or prescribed."],"reading_traps":["The source is an industry association and is classified non-official. The first card incorrectly called its coordinate coverage official in the answer.","Seven points lie outside a broad German terrestrial envelope: Mikulowa and Zielona Góra (PL), Lixhe(BE), Endrup(DK) twice and two offshore/converter points. Thus550 inside that box is not a verified German-country count.","Point categories include429 existing transformer stations,36 planned transformer stations,27 existing switching stations,3 planned switching stations, plus converters. Three category values are null.","No voltage attribute exists on station points. Adding connected-line voltage is an inference, not a published station attribute."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/json","size_bytes":229306,"records_total":557,"records_for_country":null,"problems":[]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Point layer geometry and counts were tested.","url":"https://services1.arcgis.com/LVZ4P2ZNVc4ceCSD/arcgis/rest/services/Umspannwerke/FeatureServer/0/query?where=1%3D1&returnCountOnly=true&f=json","quote":"\"count\":557"},{"claim":"Map includes existing, under-construction and implementation-planning lines.","url":"https://www.vde.com/de/fnn/dokumente/karte-deutsches-hoechstspannungsnetz","quote":"im Bau"}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s004","name":"JAO Core Static Grid Model, 9th release (2026-03)","publisher":"JAO S.A. on behalf of Core transmission system operators","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.jao.eu/static-grid-model","data_url":"https://www.jao.eu/sites/default/files/2026-06/202603_Core%20Static%20Grid%20Model_9th%20release.zip","access":"direct_download","format":"ZIP containing XLSX, DOCX handbook and HTML map","license":"unknown","language":"en","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Official selected transmission names, kV and TSO asset ownership in a joint workbook, with EIC identifiers.","first_seen_pass":null,"rank":4,"coverage":{"geographic":"Core region; German TSO rows selectable in Lines, Tielines and Transformers"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Published voltage is in kV; asset row types are documented separately in key_fields and how_to_use.","quote":"Voltage level (kV)","url":"https://www.jao.eu/sites/default/files/2026-06/202603_Core%20Static%20Grid%20Model_9th%20release.zip","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Selected Core-owned transmission assets, not a universal station register.","quote":"strictly the property of the Core TSOs.","url":"https://www.jao.eu/sites/default/files/2026-06/202603_Core%20Static%20Grid%20Model_9th%20release.zip","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"9th release labelled202603; portal lists01/03/2026; accompanying HTML filename2026-03-16.","quote":"202603_Core Static Grid Model_9th release.zip","url":"https://www.jao.eu/static-grid-model","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Six-month publication according to handbook.","quote":"every six months","url":"https://www.jao.eu/sites/default/files/2026-06/202603_Core%20Static%20Grid%20Model_9th%20release.zip","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"The handbook describes the published line operating-voltage scope as380/220kV; this is not a distribution inventory.","quote":"380/220kV","url":"https://www.jao.eu/sites/default/files/2026-06/202603_Core%20Static%20Grid%20Model_9th%20release.zip","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"TSO","meaning":"Short name of the owner of the published network asset, not necessarily site operator."},{"field":"Substation_1 / Substation_2; Full_name","meaning":"Terminals in Lines/Tielines, with grouped row1 headers."},{"field":"Voltage_level(kV)","meaning":"Operating voltage on line/tie-line."},{"field":"Primary / Secondary","meaning":"Transformer winding voltage in kV."},{"field":"EIC_Code","meaning":"Line/transformer code, not unique physical-station identifier."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL --max-time 45 'https://www.jao.eu/sites/default/files/2026-06/202603_Core%20Static%20Grid%20Model_9th%20release.zip' -o /tmp/georutter-segunda/de/jao.zip\nWorkbook: 202603_Core Static Grid Model_External.xlsx, sheets Lines/Tielines/Transformers; grouped headers row1, column labels row2, data row3.","example_result":"Lines row3: NE_name=Altdöbern - Streumen 563; EIC_Code=11T0-0000-0949-E; TSO=50HERTZ; D=Altdöbern; E=Streumen; F=380. Transformers row3: TR Eula 220/400 401; TSO=50HERTZ; Primary=400; Secondary=231.","steps":["The downloaded2495860-byte ZIP was listed and its XLSX and handbook parsed locally without executing downloaded code.","Filter columnC in Lines/Tielines/Transformers to 50HERTZ, AMPRION GMBH, TENNETGMBH, TRANSNETBW. Tested counts848 Lines,153 Tielines,133 Transformers (1,134 asset rows); all-region counts2632,333,526 respectively.","Terminal names must retain their originating asset, TSO and voltage. Tielines can terminate abroad, so German-owner rows are not a country station inventory.","Coordinates are not columns in any of these electrical sheets. The accompanying HTML has circle markers, but substation marker group has no labels/popups, so no tested exact name-to-position join is provided."],"reading_traps":["Counts are assets, not stations; multi-voltage terminals and several transformers repeat names.","German TSO filters select ownership, not geographical country. Foreign terminal names remain in tie-line rows.","The HTML’s substation markers are anonymous and include rounded coordinates. The first card’s claim of usable named municipality-level JAO locations was too strong.","TSO denotes owner of the published line/transformer. It cannot silently replace the requested station operator field."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/zip","size_bytes":2495860,"records_total":3491,"records_for_country":1134,"problems":["records_total and records_for_country are counts of selected electrical asset rows across three sheets; records_for_country means German TSO owners, not sites wholly in Germany. No workbook location coordinates."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"9th release was linked from the official joint publication page.","url":"https://www.jao.eu/static-grid-model","quote":"202603_Core Static Grid Model_9th release.zip"},{"claim":"Handbook defines asset owner field.","url":"https://www.jao.eu/sites/default/files/2026-06/202603_Core%20Static%20Grid%20Model_9th%20release.zip","quote":"TSO owner"},{"claim":"Amprion directs its users to the joint publication.","url":"https://www.amprion.net/Energy-Market/European-capacity-calculation-and-market-coupling/Static-Grid-Model/","quote":"together with the data for the core region on the JAO homepage."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s005","name":"Individual TSO publications: TenneT GIS, 50Hertz static model and TransnetBW connection map","publisher":"TenneT, 50Hertz Transmission, TransnetBW","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.50hertz.com/en/Transparency/GridData/Gridfigures/Staticgridmodel","data_url":"https://services-eu1.arcgis.com/WjozPuR5ROn6NZE8/arcgis/rest/services/Target_Grid_Map_2_0_WGS_ArcGisOnline/FeatureServer/3","access":"api","format":"ArcGIS JSON / XLSX / HTML with schematic SVG","license":"unknown","language":"de/en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Direct operator geometry for TenneT, internal node short codes for50Hertz, and targeted voltage/connection information for TransnetBW.","first_seen_pass":null,"rank":5,"coverage":{"geographic":"Individual TSO areas; no distribution coverage"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"50Hertz workbook voltage fields are in kV; TenneT sentinel and TransnetBW connection quantities are described separately.","quote":"Voltage_level(kV)","url":"https://www.50hertz.com/cdn/files/df785fbc-d4d6-4867-c6f1-08debc9147be/statisches%20netzmodell%20-%20datentabelle%202025-q4%20-%20oo.xlsx","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"50Hertz limits its described static model to the meshed transmission system. Other members have their own tested scopes.","quote":"meshed transmission system","url":"https://www.50hertz.com/en/Transparency/GridData/Gridfigures/Staticgridmodel","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"TenneT tijd=2025, layer last edit2026-02-03;50Hertz status2025-12-31; TransnetBW05/2026.","quote":"Status: 31.12.2025","url":"https://www.50hertz.com/cdn/files/df785fbc-d4d6-4867-c6f1-08debc9147be/statisches%20netzmodell%20-%20datentabelle%202025-q4%20-%20oo.xlsx","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"50Hertz states that its static model is updated at least once at year end retrospectively, or after structural changes. No fixed interval was verified for the other members.","quote":"updated at least once","url":"https://www.50hertz.com/en/Transparency/GridData/Gridfigures/Staticgridmodel","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"50Hertz excludes spur lines outside the meshed380/220kV system. Separate tests describe the other members’ gaps.","quote":"spur lines","url":"https://www.50hertz.com/en/Transparency/GridData/Gridfigures/Staticgridmodel","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"TenneT Country","meaning":"DE filter required."},{"field":"TenneT Name, Name_short, Place","meaning":"Station label, short code and locality."},{"field":"TenneT Voltage_level, SE_FLD32_SPANNINGSNIVEAU","meaning":"999 on144/144 German rows, not valid voltage evidence."},{"field":"50Hertz Full_name, Short_name","meaning":"Names and internal node identifiers, useful across operator documents."},{"field":"TransnetBW Spannungsebene","meaning":"Voltage listed only in selected station tooltips; connection timing can be future."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"https://services-eu1.arcgis.com/WjozPuR5ROn6NZE8/arcgis/rest/services/Target_Grid_Map_2_0_WGS_ArcGisOnline/FeatureServer/3/query?where=Country%3D%27DE%27&outFields=*&outSR=4326&f=json\nCount executed: https://services-eu1.arcgis.com/WjozPuR5ROn6NZE8/arcgis/rest/services/Target_Grid_Map_2_0_WGS_ArcGisOnline/FeatureServer/3/query?where=Country%3D%27DE%27&returnCountOnly=true&f=json\n50Hertz download executed: https://www.50hertz.com/cdn/files/df785fbc-d4d6-4867-c6f1-08debc9147be/statisches%20netzmodell%20-%20datentabelle%202025-q4%20-%20oo.xlsx\n50Hertz workbook sheets Lines (D/E and F/G names/codes,H kV), Tielines (D/E and G/H names/codes,I kV), Transformers(A/B names/codes,H/I primary/secondary), data row3.\nTransnetBW page inspected: https://www.transnetbw.de/de/transparenz/netzzugang-und-entgelt/netzanschlusskarte","example_result":"[{\"attributes\": {\"OBJECTID\": 1128, \"SE_FLD32_SPANNINGSNIVEAU\": 999, \"offshore\": \"onshore\", \"nieuwbouw\": \"bestaand\", \"tijd\": 2025, \"Name_short\": \"UW-HELM\", \"Name\": \"HELMSTEDT UW\", \"Place\": \"Helmstedt\", \"Voltage_level\": 999, \"Country\": \"DE\"}, \"geometry\": {\"x\": 10.99729499817271, \"y\": 52.19973098833941}}]\n50Hertz Lines row3: Eula / D8EU__2 -> Röhrsdorf / D8ROE_2,220kV. TransnetBW Daxlanden: Spannungsebene380kV, proposed connection earliest2035.","steps":["TenneT country-filtered count and full query returned144; retain x/y in4326 and country/name fields. Treat999 as unavailable voltage rather than999kV.","50Hertz has grouped headers row1 and labels row2. Preserve internal short codes and parse assets separately; no geocoding recipe was tested for their endpoint names.","TransnetBW map’s locations are schematic. Its tooltips provide names, voltage and planned availability; they do not establish exact coordinates or current operating status for future stations."],"reading_traps":["All144 TenneT DE point coordinates fall inside broad Germany envelope47.2–55.1N,5.8–15.1E, with0 outside; this is not a boundary survey.","All144 German Voltage_level and SE_FLD32_SPANNINGSNIVEAU values are999.","TransnetBW stated05/2026 on the opened page, correcting the first card’s04/2026 date. Its JavaScript manipulates SVG element colours; no geographic service was found in those inspected resources.","50Hertz has20 tie-line rows including DC/foreign endpoints; its selection differs from the JAO9th release. Do not silently equate editions."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/json","size_bytes":41824,"records_total":144,"records_for_country":144,"problems":["TenneT voltage is unavailable (999) in all German rows;50Hertz has no tabular coordinates; TransnetBW page-only schematic map. Group totals apply only to tested TenneT DE query."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"TenneT point response contains sentinel voltage.","url":"https://services-eu1.arcgis.com/WjozPuR5ROn6NZE8/arcgis/rest/services/Target_Grid_Map_2_0_WGS_ArcGisOnline/FeatureServer/3/query?where=Country%3D%27DE%27&outFields=*&outSR=4326&f=json","quote":"\"Voltage_level\":999"},{"claim":"TransnetBW page edition.","url":"https://www.transnetbw.de/de/transparenz/netzzugang-und-entgelt/netzanschlusskarte","quote":"Stand 05/2026"},{"claim":"50Hertz excludes isolated transformers.","url":"https://www.50hertz.com/en/Transparency/GridData/Gridfigures/Staticgridmodel","quote":"an isolated 220-kV grid"}],"members":[{"name":"TenneT Target Grid Map station layer","landing_url":"https://www.arcgis.com/home/item.html?id=9348e4ab5ec34cf7be54b9e00648e10f","data_url":"https://services-eu1.arcgis.com/WjozPuR5ROn6NZE8/arcgis/rest/services/Target_Grid_Map_2_0_WGS_ArcGisOnline/FeatureServer/3","access":"api","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"DE filter returned144 sites, all with Voltage_level=999 and tijd=2025. Exact precision refers to mapped points; no survey guarantee."},{"name":"50Hertz Static grid model","landing_url":"https://www.50hertz.com/en/Transparency/GridData/Gridfigures/Staticgridmodel","data_url":"https://www.50hertz.com/cdn/files/df785fbc-d4d6-4867-c6f1-08debc9147be/statisches%20netzmodell%20-%20datentabelle%202025-q4%20-%20oo.xlsx","access":"direct_download","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"2025-Q4 workbook downloaded90229 bytes,142 Lines+20 Tielines+32 Transformers; includes Full_name/Short_name, kV and asset codes but no coordinate columns."},{"name":"TransnetBW Netzanschlusskarte","landing_url":"https://www.transnetbw.de/de/transparenz/netzzugang-und-entgelt/netzanschlusskarte","data_url":null,"access":"web_viewer_only","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"Page and its map JavaScript inspected. Native schematic SVG/HTML tooltips, not a discovered geospatial endpoint. Stand05/2026 includes planned future connections."}],"members_summary":{"total":null,"listed":3,"tested":3,"data_found":0,"scope_note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null},"member_scope":{"total":null,"note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null}},{"source_id":"s006","name":"Prebuilt Electricity Network for PyPSA-Eur based on OpenStreetMap Data,0.8","publisher":"Bobby Xiong, Davide Fioriti, Fabian Neumann, Iegor Riepin and Tom Brown (TU Berlin / University of Pisa)","official":false,"landing_url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564","data_url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564/files/buses.csv?download=1","access":"direct_download","format":"CSV","license":"ODbL-1.0","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"academic","adds":"Small preprocessed transmission CSV with consistent numeric voltage and country code, avoiding a multi-GB national OSM extract.","first_seen_pass":null,"rank":6,"coverage":{"geographic":"Europe, country=DE subset"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Nearby substations within500m are aggregated to model buses; these are not one-to-one physical station records.","quote":"500 m","url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"OSM-derived transmission grid220–750kV; heuristic cleaning and aggregation.","quote":"220 kV to 750 kV","url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"0.8 retrieved2026-11-02.","quote":"retrieved on 2 November 2026","url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Continuous as data/cleaning improve, no fixed calendar.","quote":"updated continuously","url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"The tested CSV has no operator column and no below220kV German rows; this is established by the displayed header and local data inspection.","quote":"bus_id,voltage,dc,symbol,under_construction,tags,x,y,country,geometry","url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564/files/buses.csv?download=1","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"bus_id","meaning":"Model bus identifier including voltage."},{"field":"voltage","meaning":"Numeric kV, not raw OSM volts."},{"field":"tags","meaning":"Source OSM ids; can contain several ids for an aggregated model bus."},{"field":"country","meaning":"ISO country code used for DE subset."},{"field":"x,y,geometry","meaning":"Coordinates and WKT representation."},{"field":"under_construction,dc","meaning":"Model flags; not a full official operating-status register."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sS -L --max-time 45 'https://zenodo.org/records/23896564/files/buses.csv?download=1' -o /tmp/georutter-segunda/de/buses.csv\nCSV header row1; data start row2; filter country=='DE'.","example_result":"[{\"bus_id\": \"relation/17591073-220\", \"voltage\": \"220\", \"dc\": \"f\", \"symbol\": \"Substation\", \"under_construction\": \"f\", \"tags\": \"relation/17591073\", \"x\": \"8.501772\", \"y\": \"49.44484412\", \"country\": \"DE\", \"geometry\": \"POINT (8.501772 49.44484412)\"}, {\"bus_id\": \"virtual_relation/1109593:a:1-380\", \"voltage\": \"380\", \"dc\": \"f\", \"symbol\": \"Substation\", \"under_construction\": \"f\", \"tags\": \"relation/1109593;relation/1109599\", \"x\": \"7.36795125\", \"y\": \"51.62896995\", \"country\": \"DE\", \"geometry\": \"POINT (7.36795125 51.62896995)\"}]","steps":["The tested825369-byte CSV contains7017 rows,802 with countryDE; parse with CSV rules rather than comma splitting.","Filter country=DE and retain bus_id,voltage,tags,x,y,under_construction,dc. All802 have numeric voltage and lie inside broad Germany envelope47.2–55.1N,5.8–15.1E.","The DE subset has744 distinct tags strings, not necessarily744 verified physical sites. Preserve bus aggregation rather than counting buses as substations.","No operator field is provided and no authoritative operator join was tested."],"reading_traps":["802 rows are buses, not802 physical substations. There are467 rows at380kV,325 at220kV,7 at400kV and one each at320,450,525kV.","The radius500m aggregation changes the station unit and can combine nearby sites; the schema retains source ids but not a direct per-site operator field.","No110kV/MV/LV distribution rows. The academic processed voltage is not an official operator attribute.","Zenodo web fetch failed in one tool but default curl successfully opened record and CSV; this was an executor issue, not a source access restriction."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/csv","size_bytes":825369,"records_total":7017,"records_for_country":802,"problems":[]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Source describes an OSM-derived grid.","url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564","quote":"constructed using OpenStreetMap data"},{"claim":"CSV field names and example were directly tested.","url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23896564/files/buses.csv?download=1","quote":"bus_id,voltage,dc,symbol,under_construction,tags,x,y,country,geometry"}],"members":[],"members_summary":null}],"sector":{"regulator":{"name":"Bundesnetzagentur (BNetzA), with Länder regulatory authorities","url":"https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/DE/Fachthemen/ElektrizitaetundGas/VerteilerNetz/start.html"},"operators":{"structure":"many","note":"Four control-area TSOs: 50Hertz, Amprion, TenneT and TransnetBW; many distribution operators. BNetzA links an exportable MaStR Stromnetzbetreiber actor census. The tested VNBdigital directory contains 815 operators, which is a portal count rather than a statutory total.","census_url":"https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/DE/Fachthemen/ElektrizitaetundGas/Datenuebertragung_Energiedatenportal/Uebersicht_Marktakteure/start.html"},"publication_obligation":{"exists":"yes","norm":"EnWG §§14d,14e and §23c; Core Static Grid Model handbook cites Article 25(2)(f) Core DA CCM","url":"https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/enwg_2005/__14d.html","what_must_be_published":"§14d(4)(1) requires network maps including MV/LV substations and congestion regions; large DSOs submit plans, smaller DSOs transmit relevant data upstream under (9). §23c requires aggregate network statistics, not a point inventory. JAO publishes selected Core TSO electrical assets.","frequency":"DSO plans every two years by 31 October from 2026; regional scenarios ten months earlier. Core SGM every six months. §23c structural statistics annually by 1 April."},"consolidated_republication":{"found":"yes","note":"Consolidated publication exists for selected transmission electrical assets (JAO) and individual DSO reports (VNBdigital). This is not evidence of one complete all-voltage geospatial/electrical inventory.","checked_pages":[{"organization":"Bundesnetzagentur","url":"https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/DE/Fachthemen/ElektrizitaetundGas/VerteilerNetz/start.html","saw":"Collects DSO information; republishes conclusions as SMARD articles and directs individual plans to VNBdigital. The opened page did not provide a merged substation point layer."},{"organization":"SMARD / Bundesnetzagentur","url":"https://www.smard.de/page/home/wiki-article/446/215536/verteilernetzbetreiber","saw":"Explains DSO planning, §14e joint platform and coverage of the 82 large obligated operators."},{"organization":"VNBdigital","url":"https://www.vnbdigital.de/","saw":"Portal and public GraphQL directory tested: 815 operators, 96 with activated nap service. Individual PDFs, not a tested combined point table."},{"organization":"JAO on behalf of Core TSOs","url":"https://www.jao.eu/static-grid-model","saw":"Joint Core SGM download, including all four German TSOs, but selected transmission assets and no coordinate columns in workbook."}]}},"national_registry":{"exists":"yes","note":"An official nationwide topographic dataset exists: BKG republishes Länder Basis-DLM. It includes substation land-use polygons (41002, FKT2540) along recorded overhead lines and omits voltage/operator. It is a partial national source, not a complete sector registry; the national paid data were not acquired.","checked_pages":[{"organization":"BKG","url":"https://gdz.bkg.bund.de/index.php/default/digitale-geodaten/digitale-landschaftsmodelle/digitales-basis-landschaftsmodell.html","saw":"Opened nationwide product, paid licence/access conditions and official object catalogue: Umspannstation 2540 is explicitly present."},{"organization":"Bundesnetzagentur / MaStR","url":"https://www.marktstammdatenregister.de/MaStRHilfe/subpages/registrierungVerpflichtendAnlagen.html?q=pv+anlage+teile","saw":"Registration help explicitly says substations are network infrastructure and are not registered as electricity consumption units."},{"organization":"Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie","url":"https://www.bundeswirtschaftsministerium.de/Redaktion/DE/Dossier/netze-und-netzausbau.html","saw":"GET encountered a Radware browser-verification page; a second ministry FAQ route also failed through web fetch. Ministry contents were not verified."},{"organization":"Four German TSOs / Netztransparenz","url":"https://www.netztransparenz.de/de-de/%C3%9Cber-uns/Aufgaben","saw":"Opened joint operator page and followed JAO/individual static model publication; this page describes four control areas, not a unified all-voltage inventory."},{"organization":"GovData","url":"https://www.govdata.de/ckan/api/3/action/package_search?q=Umspannwerk&rows=100","saw":"The actual catalogue query returned 14 records: two Diepholz substation datasets plus planning documents/other topics. This query is not proof of national absence."}]},"if_unstructured":{"summary":null,"recipe":["The demonstrated manual extraction is the Bochum2026 report: page3 identifies operator and13 existing HS/MS stations; Figures1/2 show HS/MS and MS/NS location dots. The PDF page was rendered and inspected.","Extract the project table on pages12–14 as named records, preserving the site label, voltage wording, proposed date and status; for example UW Linden and UW Berthastr. Preserve existing-equipment statements separately from future upgrades.","The tested extraction supports operator/tier and named project evidence. Unlabelled map dots cannot be reliably attached to table names from this report alone; a complete exact station table was not recovered.","For the opened UVP notice, retain project title, applicant,380kV description and named endpoint as document evidence. Approval date remains an approval date, not an energization date."],"location_method":"The tested Bochum and UVP examples do not supply exact coordinates or cadastral references. Their maps/descriptions support only approximate/locality evidence. No method for obtaining the missing exact positions from further official annexes was completed before the research limit; the recipe does not infer them from service territories or connected lines.","cross_with":["Opened official topographic services in source2 for independently published geometries; no automatic attribute transfer was validated.","Source4 JAO for specific published transmission asset names and voltage; co-location and ownership are not treated as proof of station operator."],"where_published":[{"name":"VNBdigital individual §14d plans","url":"https://www.vnbdigital.de/","what":"Operator reports include mapped existing HS/MS and MS/NS stations and tabulated upgrade projects. The directory query returned815 operators,96 activated nap services; it is an index, not substation points.","how_to_search_inside":"Portal by operator/place; downloaded JavaScript and GraphQL directory inspected. Exact tested directory query: curl -sS --max-time 45 -H \"Content-Type: application/json\" -d '{\"query\":\"{ vnb_vnbs { _id name types services { activated type { type } } } }\"}' https://www.vnbdigital.de/gateway/graphql . Select activated nap service; a complete document-link enumeration was not tested.","example_document":{"url":"https://www.vnbdigital.de/gateway/files?serviceName=vnb&fileId=6ae4e0f723b8e2304a34428e","what_it_gives":"Stadtwerke Bochum Netz,30.10.2026,19pp. Page3:13 existing HS/MS stations,1202 MS/NS stations and two location maps. Pages12–14 name upgrade sites and voltage details: UW Linden110-kV equipment; UW Berthastr.110/10 replacement planned to110/20/10 by01/2036. Map labels and coordinates are absent."}},{"name":"Federal Umweltprüfungsportal","url":"https://www.uvp-portal.de/de/vorhaben","what":"Project-specific EIA/planning notices with authority, applicant, route description and approval dates. Federal and Länder portals are separate; not every station requires one of these notices.","how_to_search_inside":"Opened search form has Suchbegriff, place/postcode and distance filters, plus Leitungsanlagen category. A national search-result crawl was not tested.","example_document":{"url":"https://www.uvp-portal.de/de/node/1854","what_it_gives":"Vorhaben13 Pulgar–Vieselbach western section notice names50Hertz as applicant,380kV line and terminal Umspannwerk Vieselbach; decision16.08.2023. This gives no exact station coordinate or proof of all current equipment."}}]},"related_not_answering":[{"name":"MaStR equipment registry","url":"https://www.marktstammdatenregister.de/MaStRHilfe/subpages/registrierungVerpflichtendAnlagen.html?q=pv+anlage+teile","why":"Official guidance explicitly excludes substations as network infrastructure; generation/consumption units are not a substation inventory."},{"name":"VNBdigital operator directory / service regions","url":"https://www.vnbdigital.de/gateway/graphql","why":"The tested query indexes815 operators and96 activated plan services. Operator territories do not establish substation coordinates or prove the operator of a point."},{"name":"Stromnetz Berlin Open Data","url":"https://www.stromnetz.berlin/technik-und-innovationen/open-data/","why":"Opened page describes structural statistics, feed-in and tariffs, plus outage examples. The linked Berlin catalogue was not fully inspected; no station-geometry claim is made."},{"name":"LUBW Netzausbauplan service","url":"https://rips-gdi.lubw.baden-wuerttemberg.de/arcgis/rest/services/wms/Netzausbauplan/MapServer?f=pjson","why":"Tested service metadata contains a single planned transmission line layer (Polyline), not substation points; existing110kV network is a separate lead."},{"name":"ENTSO-E transmission map","url":"https://www.entsoe.eu/data/map/","why":"European transmission overview, not a verified exact all-voltage station table; no data-service extraction was completed."},{"name":"Brandenburg alkis_elektro","url":"https://energieportal-brandenburg.de/geoserver/bepo/ows/?service=WFS&version=2.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=bepo:alkis_elektro&count=3&outputFormat=application%2Fjson&srsName=EPSG:4326","why":"Sample contains generic Gebäude zur Elektrizitätsversorgung and13262 total buildings; this broader class is not automatically13262 substations."},{"name":"Uebertragungsnetz.de model","url":"https://www.uebertragungsnetz.de/about/","why":"Methodology says it combines operator static models and OSM geometries. It adds a simulation; it does not establish official geometry or a new complete registry."}],"open_questions":["The VDE layer omits ownership on473/557 features and voltage throughout; the publication does not explain whether fuller releasable attributes exist. This requires publisher clarification.","The number and accuracy of unmapped distribution sites cannot be established from OSM counts, regional topography or one operator report; no authoritative national benchmark was obtained."],"history":[],"local_terms":[{"term":"Umspannwerk (UW)","language":"de","meaning":"Transformer substation"},{"term":"Umspannstation","language":"de","meaning":"Topographic substation class and distribution transformer station"},{"term":"Ortsnetzstation","language":"de","meaning":"Local medium/low-voltage station"},{"term":"Schaltanlage / Schaltstation","language":"de","meaning":"Switching station"},{"term":"Höchstspannung / Hochspannung","language":"de","meaning":"Extra-high/high voltage; do not use as a universal transmission/distribution classifier"},{"term":"Übertragungsnetzbetreiber (ÜNB)","language":"de","meaning":"Transmission system operator"},{"term":"Verteilernetzbetreiber (VNB)","language":"de","meaning":"Distribution system operator"},{"term":"Netzausbauplan (NAP)","language":"de","meaning":"Distribution grid expansion plan"}],"provenance":{"pass_count":null,"models":[],"minutes_estimate":null,"pages_opened":null,"passes":[],"note":"Minutes are researcher estimates. Counts describe documented passes, not publication approval. Missing history or effort is not reconstructed."},"card_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/de/electrical-substations.json","detail_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/de/electrical-substations/detail.json","html_url":"https://georutter.org/de/electrical-substations/","country_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/countries/de.json"}
