{"schema_version":"1.0","country":"es","country_name":"Spain","topic":"curtailment-and-redispatch","question":"Where can I get renewable curtailment and redispatch volumes in Spain, by zone or node and by period?","territory":"es","territory_level":"country","parent_url":null,"published_on":"2026-11-19","research_reviewed_on":"2026-11-16","access_checked_on":null,"answer":{"official_data":"partial","non_official_data":"partial","summary":"REE (the TSO) publishes monthly renewable curtailment from day-ahead technical constraints by grid node (ERNI, GWh, PDF on ESIOS; Peninsula plus Baleares/Canarias in MWh). Redispatch volumes (technical-constraint energy up/down, PDBF phase I and real time) are open as national monthly/yearly series via the REData API, not by node. Per-unit data is restricted to market subjects; economic curtailment and daily series were not found public.","main_caveats":["ERNI by node is a monthly Power BI PDF export (no CSV): the table lists only the Top 30 nodes (Oct 2026: 355 of 578 GWh); the chart shows more nodes but its values need image/chart reading.","ERNI counts only D-1 phase I technical constraints vs PDBF, renewable units with specific electrical location; the report itself says node values may not match the aggregate monthly value on ESIOS.","Colours in the PDF legend decide RTT vs RTD: text extraction loses the mapping (Oct 2026: RTT 569.4 GWh, RTD 8.7 GWh read from the rendered chart).","REData energia-restricciones has no unit field; values match REE report GWh x1000 (MWh). Down values are negative. Wider period/geo options (day, baleares, ccaa) returned HTTP 400.","Redispatch (restricciones tecnicas) is not renewable-only: it includes gas/other units scheduled for voltage control and stability; do not equate it with renewable curtailment."],"confidence":"medium","confidence_reason":"Core sources opened and tested (PDF, API, report) with cross-check; ESIOS API, per-unit files and ENTSO-E could not be tested without credentials, and the full ERNI archive was only sampled by document id.","attributes":[{"attribute":"renewable_curtailment","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s001","s002"],"note":"ERNI = renewable energy not integrable due to day-ahead (D-1) grid constraints only; real-time and economic curtailment not published as such.","gap":"not_published","gap_note":"Economic curtailment and real-time curtailment: no public series found in ESIOS PDFs, REData, REE reports, CNMC (see audit.search_log)."},{"attribute":"redispatch_volume","covered":"yes","source_ids":["s002","s003"],"note":"Technical-constraint energy up/down (PDBF phase I and real time), MWh, month/year; REData and REE annual report agree for 2024-2025.","gap":null,"gap_note":null},{"attribute":"spatial_breakdown","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s001"],"note":"Curtailment by grid node (name+kV) and by RTT/RTD cause; no zone/province split. Redispatch by node or zone not published.","gap":"not_published","gap_note":"Redispatch per node: not in REData, ESIOS PDFs or REE reports; per-unit data exists only for market subjects (PO 9.1, 90 days)."},{"attribute":"reference_period","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s001","s002","s003"],"note":"ERNI: monthly (Jun 2025 to Oct 2026 found). Redispatch: month/year in REData; day returned HTTP 400; hourly only via ESIOS token (untested).","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"Daily/hourly redispatch via ESIOS API needs a token (request to consultasios@ree.es); not obtained. ERNI before Jun 2025 not located."},{"attribute":"latest_data","covered":"no","source_ids":[],"note":"Separate coverage of this canonical requirement was not established in the inherited research; see the complete source evidence.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"The previous attributes did not separately establish this requirement. The original answer and all source evidence have been retained; no new research was performed."},{"attribute":"historical_series","covered":"no","source_ids":[],"note":"Separate coverage of this canonical requirement was not established in the inherited research; see the complete source evidence.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"The previous attributes did not separately establish this requirement. The original answer and all source evidence have been retained; no new research was performed."},{"attribute":"update_frequency","covered":"no","source_ids":[],"note":"Separate coverage of this canonical requirement was not established in the inherited research; see the complete source evidence.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"The previous attributes did not separately establish this requirement. The original answer and all source evidence have been retained; no new research was performed."}]},"sources":[{"source_id":"s001","name":"ESIOS monthly publication per node of Renewable Energy Not Integrable (ERNI) due to D-1 technical constraints","publisher":"Red Electrica de Espana (ESIOS)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.esios.ree.es/es","data_url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","access":"direct_download","format":"PDF (Power BI export, 4-5 pages; chart plus Top 30 table)","license":"unknown","language":"es","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Only public curtailment volumes by grid node and by month, with the share of the node's renewable schedule.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":1,"summary":"ESIOS monthly publication per node of Renewable Energy Not Integrable (ERNI) due to D-1 technical constraints","coverage_note":"Peninsular system by transmission/distribution-connected grid node (e.g. ACECA 220); Baleares and Canarias islands in separate TNP files. Months found: 2025-06 to 2026-10 (scan of document ids; earlier months not located).","data_date":"Calendar month (Oct 2026: 01/10/2026 to 31/10/2026)","caveats":["The complete reading traps, inclusion rules, units and access evidence are in the detail. The main caveats of this card also apply."],"coverage":{"geographic":"Peninsular system by transmission/distribution-connected grid node (e.g. ACECA 220); Baleares and Canarias islands in separate TNP files. Months found: 2025-06 to 2026-10 (scan of document ids; earlier months not located)."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"GWh (peninsular files); MWh (TNP files)","quote":"ERNI (GWh) por nudo","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Renewable units with specific electrical location: biogas, biomass, onshore wind, non-UGH hydro, solar PV, solar thermal, renewable hybrids; limits from D-1 phase I technical-constraint process vs PDBF","quote":"Se consideran las unidades renovables de biogás, biomasa, eólica terrestre, hidráulica no perteneciente a una Unidad de Gestión Hidráulica, solar fotovoltaica, solar térmica e hibridación renovable.","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Calendar month (Oct 2026: 01/10/2026 to 31/10/2026)","quote":"Energía Renovable No Integrable (ERNI) por restricciones de red (D-1) del 01/10/2026 al 31/10/2026","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Monthly","quote":"Publicación mensual por nudo de la Energía Renovable No Integrable (ERNI) en el sistema peninsular por restricciones técnicas de seguridad del diario (D-1) en la red","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Only PDBF of renewable units with specific electrical location; real-time constraints and economic (market) curtailment are not part of this ERNI; node values may differ from the aggregate on ESIOS","quote":"Para estos cálculo se ha tenido únicamente los Programa Diario Base Funcionamiento (PDBF) de unidades con localización eléctrica específica de unidades renovables.","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"Nudo Tensión","meaning":"Grid node name and voltage in kV (e.g. ACECA 220); no coordinates"},{"field":"Programa PDBF renovable total por nudo (GWh)","meaning":"Renewable day-ahead base schedule at the node"},{"field":"ERNI (GWh)","meaning":"Renewable energy not integrable at the node in the month"},{"field":"% ERNI c/r PDBF renovable nudo","meaning":"ERNI divided by the node's renewable PDBF"},{"field":"% ERNI c/r PDBF renovable Peninsular","meaning":"ERNI divided by total peninsular renewable PDBF"},{"field":"Tipo de Limitación RTT/RTD","meaning":"RTT = restriccion tecnica red de transporte; RTD = red de distribucion"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL --max-time 60 -o erni_202610.pdf 'https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es' && pdftotext -f 3 -l 3 -layout erni_202610.pdf -","example_result":"ACECA 220   Programa PDBF 77,28 GWh   ERNI 36,23 GWh   46,88 % nudo   0,30 % peninsular ; ALARCOS 220   20,68   9,63   46,55 %   0,08 %. Page 2 pie: RTT 569,4 GWh (98%), RTD 8,7 GWh (2%).","steps":["Download the document by id (GET works; HEAD returns 403). 3386 is the latest-month alias; other months use separate ids, found by checking Content-Disposition (filename ERNI Nudos RR.TT PDBF Fase I_YYYYMM.pdf).","Page 3 holds the Top 30 table: parse with pdftotext -layout and a regex per row (node, kV, PDBF GWh, ERNI GWh, % node, % peninsular); decimal comma and thousands dot.","Page 2 has the bar chart with more nodes (about 56 in Oct 2026) and the RTT/RTD pie; read it as an image (pdftoppm -png -r 80) because colours carry the RTT/RTD legend.","Page 4 states the method and the RTT/RTD codes. TNP files give all island nodes in MWh with node, closing programme and %."],"reading_traps":["Top 30 table sums to 355.3 of the 578.1 GWh monthly total (Oct 2026): it is not the full list.","pdftotext output loses the colour legend: RTT is the large slice (blue) in Oct 2026; do not infer RTT/RTD from the text order.","Percent columns have two bases (node vs peninsular); node percent can reach 46.9 % while peninsular share is 0.30 %.","Filename and document id are not chronological (3386 is the rolling latest; 4245 is June 2026).","Report text: node ERNI may not match the monthly aggregate shown on the ESIOS website; unit is GWh for peninsular but MWh for TNP files."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-16","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":681400,"records_total":30,"records_for_country":30,"problems":["HEAD request returns 403 (GET returns 200)","No machine-readable table; PDF only"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Publication is monthly by node, peninsular, D-1 technical constraints","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","quote":"Publicación mensual por nudo de la Energía Renovable No Integrable (ERNI) en el sistema peninsular por restricciones técnicas de seguridad del diario (D-1) en la red"},{"claim":"Aggregate monthly share is on ESIOS and may not match","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","quote":"El valor del ERNI por nudo presentado en este informe podrá no ser coincidente con el valor mensual agregado presentado en la web del esios."},{"claim":"Island systems published separately in MWh","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3849/download?locale=es","quote":"Energía renovable no integrable (ERNI) por restricciones de red:  Baleares"}],"members":[{"name":"Peninsula, PDBF Phase I (GWh) - latest alias","landing_url":"https://www.esios.ree.es/es","data_url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","access":"direct_download","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"Document 3386 returned Oct 2026 on 2026-11-16; the ESIOS web code links to it as the current report. Other months: 3552 (2025-06), 3584 (2025-08), 3586 (2025-07), 3752 (2025-12), 3848 (2026-01), 4245 (2026-06)."},{"name":"Non-peninsular territories TNP (MWh): Baleares, Gran Canaria, Tenerife","landing_url":"https://www.esios.ree.es/es","data_url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3849/download?locale=es","access":"direct_download","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"Jan 2026; 13 pages; other TNP ids seen: 3551, 3585, 3587, 3753, 4244, 3749 (dic25), 3850 (feb26)."}],"members_summary":{"total":null,"listed":2,"tested":2,"data_found":0,"scope_note":"The inherited list is a sample or documented publisher list; successful retrieval has not been separately reclassified in this structural migration. See individual notes.","pattern":null},"member_scope":{"total":null,"note":"The inherited list is a sample or documented publisher list; successful retrieval has not been separately reclassified in this structural migration. See individual notes.","pattern":null}},{"source_id":"s002","name":"REData API widget energia-restricciones (energy by technical constraints at PDBF and in real time)","publisher":"Red Electrica de Espana (REData)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.ree.es/es/apidatos","data_url":"https://apidatos.ree.es/es/datos/mercados/energia-restricciones?start_date=2026-09-01T00:00&end_date=2026-10-31T23:59&time_trunc=month","access":"api","format":"JSON","license":"unknown","language":"es","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Machine-readable redispatch (technical-constraint) energy up/down by month or year, open without token; no node split.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":2,"summary":"REData API widget energia-restricciones (energy by technical constraints at PDBF and in real time)","coverage_note":"Peninsular system (default geo gave the same values as geo_limit=peninsular&geo_ids=8741); baleares and ccaa requests returned HTTP 400","data_date":"Series start dates per month/year (e.g. 2026-10-01); last-update fields 2026-11-01 (PDBF) and 2026-11-11 (real time)","caveats":["The complete reading traps, inclusion rules, units and access evidence are in the detail. The main caveats of this card also apply."],"coverage":{"geographic":"Peninsular system (default geo gave the same values as geo_limit=peninsular&geo_ids=8741); baleares and ccaa requests returned HTTP 400"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"MWh (inferred: yearly 2024 'a subir PDBF' 13,588,888.3 equals REE report 13.588 GWh)","quote":"Restricciones técnicas PDBF 13.588 1.717 21.340 3.611 (GWh, 2024 a subir/a bajar, 2025 a subir/a bajar)","url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","attempts":["REData JSON carries no unit field (magnitude null); ree.es/es/datos/mercados/restricciones HTML shows no unit"]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["REData apidatos page does not define the widget","ree.es/es/datos/mercados/restricciones page has no definition text"]},"reference_date":{"value":"Series start dates per month/year (e.g. 2026-10-01); last-update fields 2026-11-01 (PDBF) and 2026-11-11 (real time)","quote":"\"last-update\": \"2026-11-11T19:30:07.000+01:00\"","url":"https://apidatos.ree.es/es/datos/mercados/energia-restricciones?start_date=2026-09-01T00:00&end_date=2026-10-31T23:59&time_trunc=month","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["JSON last-update differs per series (2026-11-01 PDBF, 2026-11-11 real time); no stated schedule found on opened pages","ree.es apidatos page lists no update frequency"]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not renewable-only: includes all units scheduled by technical constraints; no page opened states exclusions","REData page does not describe the widget content"]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"included[].id 701","meaning":"Energía a subir restricciones técnicas al PDBF (fase I)"},{"field":"id 702","meaning":"Energía a bajar restricciones técnicas al PDBF (fase I) (negative values)"},{"field":"id 720","meaning":"Energía a subir restricciones en tiempo real"},{"field":"id 721","meaning":"Energía a bajar restricciones en tiempo real (negative values)"},{"field":"values[].value / datetime / percentage","meaning":"Value per period start, and share of the total"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL --max-time 60 'https://apidatos.ree.es/es/datos/mercados/energia-restricciones?start_date=2026-09-01T00:00&end_date=2026-10-31T23:59&time_trunc=month'","example_result":"id 701 Energía a subir restricciones técnicas al PDBF (fase I): 2026-09-01 2505899.7 ; 2026-10-01 2203504.6. id 702 a bajar: -991163 ; -600357.9. id 720 TR a subir: 262934.6 ; 224801.8.","steps":["GET with start_date, end_date (ISO), time_trunc=month or year; read data.included[].attributes.values.","Use geo_trunc=electric_system&geo_limit=peninsular&geo_ids=8741 explicitly if needed (same result as default).","Convert to GWh dividing by 1000 only after confirming unit against the REE annual report (matched for 2024)."],"reading_traps":["time_trunc=day returned HTTP 400 'Los datos solicitados no están disponibles' for Oct 2026; baleares and ccaa also 400.","Down (a bajar) values are negative; 'percentage' is the share of the up or down total, not of generation.","Series are all technical-constraint energy, not renewable curtailment: RTT/RTD/other split is not in the widget.","Oct 2026 PDBF-down energy 600 GWh is of the same order as ERNI 578 GWh (renewable subset): different concepts."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-16","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/json","size_bytes":2373,"records_total":4,"records_for_country":4,"problems":["No day granularity or non-peninsular geography accepted","No unit in the payload"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Widget title and id","url":"https://apidatos.ree.es/es/datos/mercados/energia-restricciones?start_date=2026-09-01T00:00&end_date=2026-10-31T23:59&time_trunc=month","quote":"\"title\": \"Energía por restricciones al PDBF y en tiempo real\", \"id\": \"mer4\""},{"claim":"Series 701 title","url":"https://apidatos.ree.es/es/datos/mercados/energia-restricciones?start_date=2026-09-01T00:00&end_date=2026-10-31T23:59&time_trunc=month","quote":"\"title\": \"Energía a subir restricciones técnicas al PDBF (fase I)\""}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s003","name":"REE Informe del Sistema Electrico 2025: Servicios de ajuste e intercambios internacionales","publisher":"Red Electrica de Espana (sistemaelectrico-ree.es)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/es/informe-del-sistema-electrico","data_url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","access":"pdf","format":"PDF (14 pages)","license":"unknown","language":"es","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Annual GWh of PDBF and real-time constraint energy, 2024 vs 2025, and a monthly chart by constraint type (transport, distribution, other).","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":3,"summary":"REE Informe del Sistema Electrico 2025: Servicios de ajuste e intercambios internacionales","coverage_note":"Peninsular system, national totals; years 2024-2025 (edition March 2026)","data_date":"Calendar year 2025 (footer: March 2026)","caveats":["The complete reading traps, inclusion rules, units and access evidence are in the detail. The main caveats of this card also apply."],"coverage":{"geographic":"Peninsular system, national totals; years 2024-2025 (edition March 2026)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"GWh","quote":"GWh     2024     2025     % 25/24","url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Report page defines no inclusion rule beyond the section title","REData does not complement it"]},"reference_date":{"value":"Calendar year 2025 (footer: March 2026)","quote":"Servicios de ajuste e intercambios internacionales. Marzo 2026","url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Annual","quote":"Servicios de ajuste e intercambios internacionales. Marzo 2026","url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["No exclusions stated on opened pages","REData comparison shows same totals"]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"Restricciones técnicas PDBF / en tiempo real","meaning":"GWh up and down, 2024 and 2025 and % change"},{"field":"Desglose de energía de restricciones al PDBF por tipo","meaning":"Monthly chart: red de transporte, red de distribución, otras causas (chart only)"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL --max-time 120 -o ajuste2025.pdf 'https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf' && pdftotext -layout ajuste2025.pdf - | grep 'Restricciones técnicas'","example_result":"Restricciones técnicas PDBF 13.588 1.717 21.340 3.611 57,0 110,3 ; Restricciones técnicas en tiempo real 5.429 701 5.091 1.487 -6,2 112,1 (GWh, 2024 up/down, 2025 up/down, % up, % down).","steps":["Page 5 table gives annual totals; page 6 chart splits PDBF constraint energy by type (read as image).","Match with REData yearly values (MWh) as a check."],"reading_traps":["Spanish thousand separator is a dot (13.588 = 13,588 GWh).","The ree.es/informes/2026/ise-2025.pdf link cited by the landing page returned 404; the sistemaelectrico-ree.es host works for the servicio-ajuste file."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-16","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":252061,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Landing page links to a www.ree.es path that returns 404; same path on sistemaelectrico-ree.es works"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Annual constraint energy","url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","quote":"Restricciones técnicas PDBF                 13.588          1.717       21.340       3.611        57,0        110,3"}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s004","name":"ESIOS API indicators (technical constraints and % ERNI)","publisher":"Red Electrica de Espana (ESIOS)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/doc/indicator/getting_a_list_of_indicators_filtered_by_taxonomy_term_ids.html","data_url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/indicators","access":"registration_required","format":"JSON","license":"unknown","language":"es","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Hourly/daily indicator series and % ERNI aggregates (peninsular and non-peninsular) for longer or finer periods than REData; requires a personal token.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":4,"coverage":{"geographic":"Peninsular and non-peninsular systems; indicator ids 10460, 10461, 10462 (% ERNI RRTT RT, RTD, total) and 10488-10490 (SNP) appear in the ESIOS web application code"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Indicators not queried (no token)","ESIOS pages are JavaScript; unit not visible"]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not queried","No indicator description reachable"]},"reference_date":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not queried","No page opened"]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not queried","No page opened"]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not queried","No page opened"]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"indicator id","meaning":"10460/10461/10462 = % ERNI RRTT (RT, RTD, total) as labelled in ESIOS web code; 701/702/720/721 share ids with REData series (not verified against ESIOS)"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL --max-time 30 'https://api.esios.ree.es/indicators'","example_result":"{\"Status\":403,\"message\":\"Forbidden\"} (no token)","steps":["Request a personal token by email to consultasios@ree.es (per the evcc documentation page), then send it in the x-api-key header (ESIOS API doc page) and list indicators with GET /indicators."],"reading_traps":["api.esios.ree.es/documents/<id>/download works without token but /documents, /indicators and /archives return 403.","The site's own data calls use another host; not used."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-16","method":"blocked","http_status":403,"content_type":"application/json","size_bytes":null,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Token required; API doc pages behind Incapsula return 403 to curl"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"API authentication by x-api-key and indicator listing","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/doc/indicator/getting_a_list_of_indicators_filtered_by_taxonomy_term_ids.html","quote":"GET /indicators?taxonomy_ids[]=1&taxonomy_ids[]=2 (header x-api-key)"},{"claim":"Token request route","url":"https://docs.evcc.io/en/tariffs/ree","quote":"Request your token at consultasios@ree.es"}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s005","name":"ESIOS settlement files per programming unit (I90/liquidation files)","publisher":"Red Electrica de Espana (sujetos.esios.ree.es)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://ree.es/sites/default/files/2024-11/PO_9_1_BOE-A-2024-11535.pdf","data_url":null,"access":"registration_required","format":"zip with pdf and text files","license":"unknown","language":"es","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Detail by programming unit for constraint energy and prices (PO 9.1: 90 days after the programming day); unit-level is the closest to node or zone location.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":5,"coverage":{"geographic":"Peninsular system by programming unit; only for registered market subjects with a REE/OMEL card"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not opened (restricted)","Guide PDF does not state units"]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not opened","Guide describes access only"]},"reference_date":{"value":"Per programming day; per-unit detail 90 days later","quote":"Por unidad de programación, a los 90 días respecto al día de programación, incluyendo precios de asignación y limitaciones establecidas por seguridad.","url":"https://ree.es/sites/default/files/2024-11/PO_9_1_BOE-A-2024-11535.pdf","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["PO 9.1 gives lags only","No schedule page for files found"]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not opened","Restricted"]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"unit of programming (UP)","meaning":"Per-unit constraint energy, prices and security limitations; mapping UP to node needs REE unit lists (not checked)"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"Page only: https://www.ree.es/sites/default/files/12_CLIENTES/Documentos/Acceso_a_ficheros_de_liquidaciones_desde_esios_.pdf","example_result":"Guide: 'Disponer de una tarjeta emitida por REE o por OMEL' to reach sujetos.esios.ree.es","steps":["Access requires a market-subject card; PO 9.1 says per-unit constraint results are made available after 90 days."],"reading_traps":["The settlement guide describes liquidation files by MEFF/REE; whether public ESIOS offers a per-UP constraints file was not found."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-16","method":"page_only","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":677828,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Restricted to market subjects with card"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Per-unit results after 90 days","url":"https://ree.es/sites/default/files/2024-11/PO_9_1_BOE-A-2024-11535.pdf","quote":"Por unidad de programación, a los 90 días respecto al día de programación, incluyendo precios de asignación y limitaciones establecidas por seguridad."},{"claim":"Access requires card","url":"https://www.ree.es/sites/default/files/12_CLIENTES/Documentos/Acceso_a_ficheros_de_liquidaciones_desde_esios_.pdf","quote":"Disponer de una tarjeta emitida por REE o por OMEL."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s006","name":"ENTSO-E Transparency Platform: redispatching (art. 13.1.a) and countertrading","publisher":"ENTSO-E","official":true,"landing_url":"https://eepublicdownloads.entsoe.eu/clean-documents/Transparency/MoP_Ref2_DDD_v3r4.pdf","data_url":"https://web-api.tp.entsoe.eu/api","access":"registration_required","format":"XML via API","license":"unknown","language":"en","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","publisher_type":"supranational","adds":"EU-wide redispatch volumes (MWh) by control area, with network element and reason, if Spain reports them; not verified for Spain.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":6,"coverage":{"geographic":"EU TSOs; Spain's presence in the redispatching dataset not verified"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"MWh","quote":"Redispatched energy (MWh) resulting from changes of affected generation/load capacity.","url":"https://eepublicdownloads.entsoe.eu/clean-documents/Transparency/MoP_Ref2_DDD_v3r4.pdf","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["DDD note excludes central-dispatch systems (Italy, Poland, Greece, Ireland, Northern Ireland); Spain not listed","Spain data not queried"]},"reference_date":{"value":"Per market time unit","quote":"Information relating to redispatching per market time unit","url":"https://eepublicdownloads.entsoe.eu/clean-documents/Transparency/MoP_Ref2_DDD_v3r4.pdf","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["DDD: optionally H+1 and updated on D+1 for the network element","Spain feed not checked"]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Not queried","No page for Spain opened"]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"network element EIC","meaning":"Location of the congestion causing redispatch (per DDD)"},{"field":"redispatched energy (MWh)","meaning":"Generation/load up and down per market time unit"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL 'https://web-api.tp.entsoe.eu/api?documentType=A63&processType=A16&businessType=A46&in_Domain=10YES-REE------0&out_Domain=10YES-REE------0&periodStart=202610010000&periodEnd=202610020000'","example_result":"Acknowledgement_MarketDocument, Reason code 999 'Authentication failed.' (HTTP 401); parameters guessed, not validated.","steps":["Needs an ENTSO-E account token; consult the Transparency Platform redispatching view while logged in."],"reading_traps":["The document type and domain parameters in my request were not validated; the failure was authentication."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-16","method":"blocked","http_status":401,"content_type":"application/xml","size_bytes":null,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Token required; the transparency.entsoe.eu viewer is JavaScript-only"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Redispatching data scope per DDD","url":"https://eepublicdownloads.entsoe.eu/clean-documents/Transparency/MoP_Ref2_DDD_v3r4.pdf","quote":"Information relating to redispatching per market time unit,"}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s007","name":"Commercial node-level curtailment tools (eRoots, Fcirce)","publisher":"eRoots; Fcirce (CIRCE)","official":false,"landing_url":"https://www.pv-magazine.com/2026/09/29/digital-map-forecasts-spains-grid-constraints-and-curtailment-hotspots-for-2027/","data_url":null,"access":"paid","format":"web platform","license":"commercial","language":"en","has_coordinates":null,"location_precision":null,"publisher_type":"commercial","adds":"Paid node-level curtailment forecasts and maps; only named.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":7,"coverage":{"geographic":"Iberian grid (eRoots); node-level (Fcirce)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Paid; not opened","Article gives no unit"]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Paid","Not opened"]},"reference_date":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Paid","Not opened"]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Paid","Not opened"]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":["Paid","Not opened"]}},"key_fields":[{"field":null,"meaning":null}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":null,"example_result":null,"steps":[],"reading_traps":["Forecasts and modelled values, not REE published volumes."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-16","method":"page_only","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/html","size_bytes":null,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Paid or on request"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"eRoots node-level subscription map","url":"https://www.pv-magazine.com/2026/09/29/digital-map-forecasts-spains-grid-constraints-and-curtailment-hotspots-for-2027/","quote":"The platform is available under several subscription plans"}],"members":[{"name":"eRoots digital map of the Iberian grid","landing_url":"https://www.pv-magazine.com/2026/09/29/digital-map-forecasts-spains-grid-constraints-and-curtailment-hotspots-for-2027/","data_url":null,"access":"paid","tested":false,"data_found":null,"note":"Subscription plans per the article; 8,175 nodes modelled"},{"name":"Fcirce curtailment calculation tool","landing_url":"https://www.fcirce.es/en/services/calculation-and-solution-tool-curtailment-grid","data_url":null,"access":"request_form","tested":false,"data_found":null,"note":"Request-information service; uses REE grid model and planning model"}],"members_summary":{"total":null,"listed":2,"tested":0,"data_found":0,"scope_note":"The inherited list is a sample or documented publisher list; successful retrieval has not been separately reclassified in this structural migration. See individual notes.","pattern":null},"member_scope":{"total":null,"note":"The inherited list is a sample or documented publisher list; successful retrieval has not been separately reclassified in this structural migration. See individual notes.","pattern":null}}],"sector":{"regulator":{"name":"CNMC (Comision Nacional de los Mercados y la Competencia)","url":"https://cnmc.es/prensa/procedimientos-control-tension-20260710"},"operators":{"structure":"single","note":"Red Electrica (REE, Redeia) is the single system operator and TSO that schedules technical constraints; distribution operators (many) cause RTD constraints but do not publish this data.","census_url":null},"publication_obligation":{"exists":"yes","norm":"P.O. 9.1 section 1.11 (BOE-A-2024-11535, resolution of 6 June 2024; later versions may exist)","url":"https://ree.es/sites/default/files/2024-11/PO_9_1_BOE-A-2024-11535.pdf","what_must_be_published":"Aggregated energy by direction and limitation type and average price of technical-constraints solution (PDBF and real time) within 30 min; aggregates in 3 days; per market participant after 1 month; per programming unit after 90 days.","frequency":"Per programming period (quarter-hour) for aggregates; monthly and 90-day lags for detail"},"consolidated_republication":{"found":"yes","note":"REE republishes its own data; no third-party aggregator republication of node data found (only paid tools).","checked_pages":[{"organization":"REE / ESIOS","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","saw":"Monthly ERNI by node publication (Oct 2026) hosted on the ESIOS API documents store"},{"organization":"REE / REData","url":"https://apidatos.ree.es/es/datos/mercados/energia-restricciones?start_date=2026-09-01T00:00&end_date=2026-10-31T23:59&time_trunc=month","saw":"Open JSON widget with technical-constraint energy up/down, PDBF phase I and real time"},{"organization":"REE / Sistema Electrico","url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","saw":"Annual report: technical constraints PDBF 21,340 GWh up in 2025"},{"organization":"CNMC","url":"https://cnmc.es/prensa/procedimientos-control-tension-20260710","saw":"July 2026 press note: REE must publish periodic information on zonal voltage-control needs; nothing on node curtailment data"}]}},"national_registry":{"exists":"partial","note":"REE publishes official nodal ERNI and aggregate redispatch publicly, but only monthly PDFs/aggregates; no single open dataset by node or zone and no public per-unit redispatch.","checked_pages":[{"organization":"REE / ESIOS","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","saw":"ERNI by node PDF, Top 30 table plus chart"},{"organization":"CNMC","url":"https://cnmc.es/sites/default/files/5779264.pdf","saw":"2023 wholesale market supervision report; section 2.7.1 technical constraints at PDBF shown as cost/centrales-dia charts, no node volumes"},{"organization":"MITECO","url":"https://www.miteco.gob.es/es/prensa/ultimas-noticias/2025/octubre/el-miteco-mejora-la-regulacion-de-las-renovables-para-adaptarla-.html","saw":"Oct 2025 note on energy not sold due to technical constraints and operating hours; no data publication"},{"organization":"ENTSO-E","url":"https://eepublicdownloads.entsoe.eu/clean-documents/Transparency/MoP_Ref2_DDD_v3r4.pdf","saw":"Data description for redispatching per market time unit (art. 13.1.a); Spain not among excluded central-dispatch systems; actual ES data not verified"}]},"if_unstructured":{"summary":null,"recipe":["Fetch each monthly ERNI PDF by id (GET) and run pdftotext -layout on page 3; parse rows with a regex (tested on Oct 2026: 30 rows, sum 355.27 GWh of 578.1 total).","Read page 2 as image to get chart nodes beyond the Top 30 and the RTT/RTD split (RTT 569.4 GWh, RTD 8.7 GWh in Oct 2026).","For island systems use the TNP file (MWh) with the table 'Nudo tensión | Programa de cierre renovable total por nudo | ERNI RR.TT. | % ...'.","For redispatch totals use REData energia-restricciones (MWh) and cross-check with the REE annual report (GWh)."],"location_method":"No coordinates: node names (e.g. ACECA 220) must be matched to substations in REE grid data or OSM manually; precision is substation-level only if the match is confirmed (not tested here).","cross_with":["REE transmission substation list or OSM substations for node position","REData generation by technology for context","ESIOS indicators for aggregate % ERNI (token)"],"where_published":[{"name":"ESIOS ERNI monthly documents","url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","what":"Monthly PDF per node (peninsular) and islands (TNP)","how_to_search_inside":"No listing page found for curl; document ids are not chronological; check Content-Disposition by id with Range GET. Ids found: 3552, 3584, 3586, 3752, 3848, 4245 (peninsular); 3551, 3585, 3587, 3749, 3753, 3849, 3850, 4244 (TNP).","example_document":{"url":"https://api.esios.ree.es/documents/3386/download?locale=es","what_it_gives":"Page 3: 'ACECA 220 | 77,28 | 36,23 | 46,88 % | 0,30 %' (PDBF GWh, ERNI GWh, % node, % peninsular); page 2 pie 'RTT 569,4 (98%)' 'RTD 8,7 (2%)'."}},{"name":"REE servicios de ajuste annual report","url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","what":"Annual constraint energy GWh 2024-2025","how_to_search_inside":"Landing page https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/es/informe-del-sistema-electrico; page 5 table","example_document":{"url":"https://www.sistemaelectrico-ree.es/sites/default/files/informes/2026/servicio-ajuste-2025.pdf","what_it_gives":"Page 5: 'Restricciones técnicas PDBF 13.588 1.717 21.340 3.611' (GWh)."}},{"name":"BOE / REE operation procedures (PO 3.2, PO 9.1)","url":"https://ree.es/sites/default/files/2024-11/PO_9_1_BOE-A-2024-11535.pdf","what":"Rules for constraints solution and what REE must publish","how_to_search_inside":"BOE search by procedure name; REE hosts consolidated PDFs","example_document":{"url":"https://ree.es/sites/default/files/2024-11/PO_9_1_BOE-A-2024-11535.pdf","what_it_gives":"Section 1.11: 'Por unidad de programación, a los 90 días respecto al día de programación'."}}]},"related_not_answering":[{"name":"CNMC wholesale market supervision report 2023 (IS/DE/013/24)","url":"https://cnmc.es/sites/default/files/5779264.pdf","why":"Section 2.7.1 shows national PDBF constraint cost and plant-days in charts, not volumes by node or renewable curtailment."},{"name":"Press figures by province (Xataka, 2025)","url":"https://www.xataka.com/energia/espana-esta-perdiendo-30-su-energia-renovable-eje-toledo-ciudad-real-granada","why":"Secondary article: cites a REE report, gives per-node percentages, no dataset; the 30% is the top node, not a province total."},{"name":"Aurora Energy Research curtailment forecast (via pv magazine)","url":"https://www.pv-magazine.com/2026/03/02/high-pv-curtailment-expected-in-spain-through-2027/","why":"Modelled forecast without named source; not published volumes."},{"name":"CNMC press note on PO 7.4 / 14.4 (voltage control)","url":"https://cnmc.es/prensa/procedimientos-control-tension-20260710","why":"Requires REE to publish zonal voltage-control needs; that is a needs publication, not curtailment or redispatch volumes."}],"open_questions":["ESIOS public pages are JavaScript-only: whether a public listing of all ERNI documents or a downloadable ERNI node series exists could not be confirmed by curl; REE would need to be asked."],"history":[{"pass":1,"date":"2026-11-16","role":"research","model":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (High)","rules_version":"6.12","note":"First pass: REE publishes monthly ERNI by grid node (PDF) and aggregate redispatch volumes (REData API, no token); redispatch by node/zone is not published.","headline":{"official_data":"partial","non_official_data":"partial","national_registry":"partial"},"sources":{"total":7,"new":7,"dropped":0},"negatives":{"overturned":0,"confirmed":0},"effort":{"pages":38,"minutes":12}}],"local_terms":[{"term":"restricciones técnicas","language":"es","meaning":"Technical constraints; the process (PO 3.2) that redispatches units to solve grid problems"},{"term":"ERNI (energía renovable no integrable)","language":"es","meaning":"Renewable energy that cannot be integrated; REE's curtailment measure by node"},{"term":"vertidos / curtailment","language":"es/en","meaning":"Press terms for non-integrated renewable energy"},{"term":"RTT / RTD","language":"es","meaning":"Restricción técnica de red de transporte / de distribución"},{"term":"PDBF / PDVP","language":"es","meaning":"Programa Diario Base de Funcionamiento / Programa Diario Viable Provisional"},{"term":"nudo","language":"es","meaning":"Grid node (substation busbar by name and kV)"},{"term":"TNP / SNP","language":"es","meaning":"Territorios / sistemas no peninsulares (islands)"},{"term":"unidad de programación (UP)","language":"es","meaning":"Scheduling unit used for per-unit constraint results"}],"provenance":{"pass_count":1,"models":["Claude Sonnet 5.5 (High)"],"minutes_estimate":12,"pages_opened":38,"passes":[{"pass":1,"date":"2026-11-16","model":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (High)"}],"note":"Minutes are researcher estimates. Counts describe documented passes, not publication approval. Missing history or effort is not reconstructed."},"card_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/es/curtailment-and-redispatch.json","detail_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/es/curtailment-and-redispatch/detail.json","html_url":"https://georutter.org/es/curtailment-and-redispatch/","country_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/countries/es.json"}
