{"schema_version":"1.0","country":"us","country_name":"United States","topic":"curtailment-and-redispatch","question":"Where can I get renewable curtailment and redispatch volumes in the United States, by zone or node and by period?","territory":"us","territory_level":"country","parent_url":null,"published_on":"2026-11-20","research_reviewed_on":"2026-11-20","access_checked_on":"2026-11-20","answer":{"official_data":"partial","non_official_data":"not_tested","summary":"Only CAISO publishes a full series. Its daily renewable report gives curtailed wind and solar MWh by hour, five minutes, day and month, by type and local/system reason; a monthly CSV runs May 2014 to October 2026 (2024: 3,423,376; 2025: 3,766,065) and reconciles with the five-minute file and EIA. CAISO states exceptional-dispatch volume monthly (Sep 2026: 64,296 MWh), the nearest redispatch analogue. MISO shows daily average curtailment in MW only as PDF chart labels; ERCOT's market monitor gives annual percentages. No zone or node values were found; ERCOT's SCED disclosure was blocked.","main_caveats":["Coverage is uneven: CAISO has MWh series; MISO only daily average MW in PDF charts; ERCOT only annual percentages (market monitor); other operators not opened.","Definitions differ: legacy CAISO PDFs measure against forecast, the market report against the dispatch upper limit; ERCOT's figures cover congestion curtailment.","CAISO's exceptional dispatch is manual out-of-market dispatch, not market redispatch; no other operator's redispatch volume was checked.","No zone or node values: CAISO local/system reason, MISO and ERCOT are system-wide; ERCOT's SCED disclosure blocked scripted access (403).","CAISO's PDF reports and five-minute workbook ended 2025-06-01; the daily HTML report holds its data as chart scripts, not a file; 'Operator Instruction' is undefined there.","The monthly CSV has no unit; MWh is inferred from EIA's 2024 figure and the five-minute file."],"confidence":"medium","confidence_reason":"CAISO series were downloaded and reconciled (monthly CSV, five-minute file, EIA). MISO and ERCOT rest on one report each; other operators and ERCOT node data were not verified.","attributes":[{"attribute":"renewable_curtailment","covered":"partial","source_ids":["caiso-daily-renewable-reports","caiso-curtailments-monthly-csv","miso-monthly-operations-report","ercot-imm-state-of-the-market-2025"],"note":"CAISO gives MWh with definitions; MISO daily average MW (PDF charts); ERCOT annual percentages (monitor).","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"Only CAISO has MWh series with definitions; SPP, PJM, NYISO and ISO-NE pages were not opened and ERCOT's SCED disclosure returned 403. Definitions differ (forecast-based vs dispatch-limit-based; congestion only at ERCOT)."},{"attribute":"redispatch_volume","covered":"partial","source_ids":["caiso-market-performance-report"],"note":"CAISO exceptional-dispatch MWh per month (Sep 2026: 64,296), incremental/decremental in figures.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"Exceptional dispatch is manual out-of-market dispatch, not market redispatch; no volume series was checked at ERCOT, MISO, SPP, PJM or NYISO and CAISO's direction split exists only as images."},{"attribute":"spatial_breakdown","covered":"no","source_ids":[],"note":"Only system level with Local/System reason (CAISO), MISO-wide MW and ERCOT-wide percentages; no zone or node volumes found.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"CAISO and MISO publish no zone or node values in the files read; ERCOT's resource-level SCED disclosure (60-day delay) was blocked (403) and other operators were not opened."},{"attribute":"reference_period","covered":"yes","source_ids":["caiso-daily-renewable-reports","caiso-curtailments-monthly-csv","caiso-production-curtailments-xlsx"],"note":"CAISO: five-minute, hourly, daily and monthly periods with explicit dates; publication posted about 10:00 AM next day.","gap":null,"gap_note":null},{"attribute":"latest_data","covered":"yes","source_ids":["caiso-daily-renewable-reports","caiso-curtailments-monthly-csv","caiso-market-performance-report"],"note":"Daily report for Nov 18, 2026 (posted 11/19); monthly CSV through Oct 2026; market report through Sep 2026.","gap":null,"gap_note":null},{"attribute":"historical_series","covered":"yes","source_ids":["caiso-curtailments-monthly-csv","caiso-production-curtailments-xlsx","caiso-daily-curtailment-pdfs"],"note":"Monthly CSV May 2014-Oct 2026 (150 months, no gaps); five-minute 2025; daily PDFs to May 2025; definitions and labels changed over time.","gap":null,"gap_note":null},{"attribute":"update_frequency","covered":"yes","source_ids":["caiso-daily-renewable-reports","caiso-market-performance-report"],"note":"Daily reports (observed ~10:00 AM next day, 18 consecutive in Nov 2026); monthly market report; legacy PDFs said 'produced daily'.","gap":null,"gap_note":null}]},"sources":[{"source_id":"caiso-daily-renewable-reports","name":"Daily Renewable Report (curtailment of variable energy resources, CAISO)","publisher":"California ISO (CAISO), Market Analysis","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-renewable-reports","data_url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/daily-renewable-report-nov-18-2026.html","access":"web_viewer_only","format":"HTML report page with Highcharts charts; the values sit in embedded JavaScript arrays (curt_hourly_*, curt_five_min_*, curt_daily_*, curt_monthly_ytd_*)","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","adds":"Current CAISO series: curtailed wind and solar energy (MWh) and maximum (MW) by hour, five-minute interval, day, month and year to date, split by type (Economic, Self Schedule Cut, Operator Instruction) and reason (Local, System).","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":1,"summary":"CAISO's daily renewable report gives curtailed wind and solar energy (MWh) by hour, five minutes, day and month, split by type (economic, self-schedule cut, operator instruction) and reason (local, system).","coverage_note":"CAISO system level, no zone or node; latest listed report Nov 18, 2026 (posted the next morning).","data_date":"2026-11-18","caveats":["Values are embedded in HTML chart scripts, not a data file.","Operator Instruction is not defined on the report (legacy label: ExDispatch)."],"coverage":{"geographic":"CAISO system level (not by zone, node or resource). The report also lists WEIM generation awards; WEIM curtailment treatment was not verified."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Curtailed energy in MWh and maximum curtailment in MW for wind and solar variable energy resources (VER), per interval.","quote":"Hourly VER Generation Curtailment Energy in MWh Maximum VER Curtailment in MW for the hour Five Minute VER Generation Curtailment Energy in MWh","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/daily-renewable-report-nov-18-2026.html","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Curtailment of VER resources at system level; the legacy PDFs defined curtailment against forecast, the market report defines economic curtailment against the dispatch upper limit.","quote":"Economic curtailment is defined as the resource’s dispatch upper limit minus its RTD schedule when the resource has an economic bid.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/feb-2026/renewable-resource.html","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Report day (UTC date in the page script) Nov 18, 2026; listed as posted 11/19/2026, 10:00 AM.","quote":"Daily Renewable Report Nov 18, 2026 105.78 KB Report 11/19/2026, 10:00 AM","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-renewable-reports-nov-2026","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Daily, posted about 10:00 AM the next day (observed for 18 consecutive daily reports in November 2026).","quote":null,"url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-renewable-reports-nov-2026","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/daily-renewable-report-nov-18-2026.html","note":"Definition of 'Operator Instruction' not found on the report; the legacy PDFs used 'ExDispatch' (exceptional dispatch). The mapping is an inference."}]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"curt_hourly_econ_local / econ_system / ss_local / ss_system / oi_local / oi_system","meaning":"24 hourly values (MWh) of the report day by type and reason."},{"field":"curt_five_min_*","meaning":"Five-minute curtailment energy series of the report day."},{"field":"curt_daily_*_mwh and curt_daily_*_mw","meaning":"15 daily totals (MWh) and daily maxima (MW) ending on the report day."},{"field":"curt_hr_tot_solar_* / curt_hr_tot_wind_*","meaning":"Hourly curtailed MWh split by fuel (solar, wind)."},{"field":"curt_monthly_ytd_*_mwh / curt_monthly_ytd_perc_mwh","meaning":"Year-to-date monthly curtailed MWh by type and the monthly percentage compared with actuals (13 values)."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -L -A 'client/1.0' -o r.html https://www.caiso.com/documents/daily-renewable-report-nov-18-2026.html  # then read the JavaScript arrays curt_hourly_econ_local, curt_daily_econ_local_mwh, curt_monthly_ytd_econ_local_mwh ... from the largest <script> block","example_result":"Report day 2026-11-18: hourly curtailment 2,016.6 MWh (Economic-Local 1,989.6, Economic-System 26.9, Self Schedule Cut-Local 0.1); last 15 days 94,497.7 MWh; year-to-date Jan-Nov 18, 2026 about 5,424,087 MWh by type.","steps":["List the month page (e.g. /library/daily-renewable-reports-nov-2026) to find the report links /documents/daily-renewable-report-<mon>-<dd>-<yyyy>.html.","Download the HTML and parse the arrays by variable name.","Sum the six type/reason arrays for total curtailment."],"reading_traps":["The data are not in a data file: they are chart arrays in the HTML.","Hourly arrays hold the report day only; use the daily and monthly arrays for history.","Type labels differ from the legacy PDFs (Operator Instruction vs ExDispatch)."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/html","size_bytes":108315,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["No machine-readable data file or API: values extracted from embedded script arrays.","Only the Nov 18, 2026 report was parsed (monthly YTD arrays reconcile with the monthly CSV: Jan-Oct 2026 5,297,888 MWh plus Nov 1-18 about 126,194 MWh against 5,424,087 MWh)."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Replacement of the earlier PDF reports.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-reports","quote":"As of 06/01/2025 the ISO is no longer generating these reports. Please see the daily renewable reports."},{"claim":"Report sections include curtailment of VER resources at system level.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/daily-renewable-report-nov-18-2026.html","quote":"Curtailment of VER Resources - System Level Hourly VER Generation Curtailment Energy in MWh"},{"claim":"Posting time of the latest listed report.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-renewable-reports-nov-2026","quote":"Daily Renewable Report Nov 18, 2026 105.78 KB Report 11/19/2026, 10:00 AM"}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"caiso-curtailments-monthly-csv","name":"CAISO monthly wind and solar curtailment series (curtailments-monthly.csv)","publisher":"California ISO (CAISO)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.caiso.com/about/our-business/managing-the-evolving-grid","data_url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/charts/curtailments-monthly.csv","access":"direct_download","format":"CSV (Date, Wind and solar curtailment, with a date-like header in the third column)","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","adds":"Single 150-row monthly series from May 2014 to October 2026, the longest continuous curtailment history found.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":2,"summary":"A 150-row monthly CSV of CAISO wind and solar curtailment from May 2014 to October 2026 (2024: 3,423,376; 2025: 3,766,065 per the file; unit inferred as MWh).","coverage_note":"System level, monthly; no type, reason or zone breakdown.","data_date":"2026-10","caveats":["Unit is not stated in the file.","Thousands separators in some cells."],"coverage":{"geographic":"CAISO system level."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Monthly wind and solar curtailment; unit not stated in the file. Annual sums match EIA's MWh figure for 2024 and the five-minute file converted to MWh, so MWh is inferred.","quote":null,"url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/charts/curtailments-monthly.csv","attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/charts/curtailments-monthly.csv","note":"Header has no unit."}]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/about/our-business/managing-the-evolving-grid","note":"Page links the CSV under a renewable curtailment anchor; the text describing the series was not read."}]},"reference_date":{"value":"Months 2014-05 to 2026-10; third header cell reads 11/6/2026 (read as the update date, unconfirmed).","quote":null,"url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/charts/curtailments-monthly.csv","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/charts/curtailments-monthly.csv","note":"No schedule stated; October 2026 was present on 2026-11-20 and the header date is 11/6/2026."}]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"Date","meaning":"First day of the month (M/D/YYYY)."},{"field":"Wind and solar curtailment","meaning":"Monthly curtailed energy; some values contain a thousands separator inside quotes (e.g. \"182,465\")."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -L -A 'client/1.0' -o curtailments-monthly.csv https://www.caiso.com/content/charts/curtailments-monthly.csv","example_result":"150 monthly rows; yearly sums: 2023 2,659,527; 2024 3,423,376; 2025 3,766,065; 2026 (Jan-Oct) 5,297,888. October 2026: 182,465.","steps":["Parse with a CSV reader and strip thousands separators.","Sum by year if needed."],"reading_traps":["Unit is not stated in the file.","Thousands separators appear in some cells.","Third header cell contains a date, not a column name."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/csv","size_bytes":2672,"records_total":150,"records_for_country":150,"problems":["Unit and definition not published in the file; EIA's Today in Energy (May 28, 2025) reports 3.4 million MWh of CAISO wind and solar curtailment in 2024 and a 29% increase, matching the 2024 and 2023 sums here."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Independent figure for 2024.","url":"https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=65364","quote":"In 2024, CAISO curtailed 3.4 million megawatthours (MWh) of utility-scale wind and solar output, a 29% increase from the amount of electricity curtailed in 2023."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"caiso-market-performance-report","name":"CAISO Market Performance Report (Section 10 Market Manual Adjustment: exceptional dispatch; Section 11 Renewable Resource)","publisher":"California ISO (CAISO), Department of Market Monitoring and Market Analysis","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/","data_url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/sep-2026/market-manual-adjustment.html","access":"web_viewer_only","format":"HTML report (one page per section per month) with PNG figures","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","adds":"Monthly exceptional-dispatch volume in MWh (the closest published analogue of redispatch) and the official definitions of economic, self-schedule and exceptional-dispatch curtailment.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":3,"summary":"CAISO's monthly Market Performance Report states exceptional-dispatch volume in MWh (Sep 2026: 64,296) with incremental/decremental and reason figures, and defines how renewable curtailment is measured.","coverage_note":"System level, monthly, latest September 2026; reports reachable back to at least January 2023.","data_date":"2026-09","caveats":["Exceptional dispatch is not the same as market redispatch.","Daily and directional splits are only in images."],"coverage":{"geographic":"CAISO system level."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"MWh of exceptional dispatch (commitments and energy dispatches; incremental and decremental).","quote":"The total volume is calculated as sum of physical minimum of the resource, uneconomical incremental exceptional dispatch or uneconomical decremental exceptional dispatch.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/sep-2026/market-manual-adjustment.html","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Exceptional dispatch instructions logged by operators with a reason.","quote":"The ISO issues exceptional dispatch instructions primarily to manage constraints that are not modeled in the market software.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/sep-2026/market-manual-adjustment.html","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Monthly; latest report September 2026 (october-2026 pages returned 404 on 2026-11-20).","quote":"The total volume of exceptional dispatch increased from 45,706 MWh in August 2026 to 64,296 MWh in September 2026.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/sep-2026/market-manual-adjustment.html","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Monthly (reports for Jan 2023, Jan 2024, Jan 2025, Jun 2025, Dec 2025, Jan 2026, Feb 2026 and Sep 2026 answered 200).","quote":null,"url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/sep-2026/market-manual-adjustment.html","note":"Market-based congestion management inside the LMP market is not reported as a redispatch volume."}]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"Total Exceptional Dispatch Volume (MWh) by Reason","meaning":"Daily figure (PNG) by reason: Bridging Schedules, Load Forecast Uncertainty, Planned Transmission Outage, Reliability Assessment, Emergency Assistance, Ramping Capacity, Voltage Support, Other."},{"field":"Total Exceptional Dispatch Volume (MWh) by Instruction Type","meaning":"Incremental versus decremental volume (figure 10.2)."},{"field":"Renewable Curtailment by Reason / by Resource Type","meaning":"Figures 11.1 and 11.2: system-wide conditions versus local congestion; solar versus wind."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -L -A 'client/1.0' https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/sep-2026/market-manual-adjustment.html  # read the sentence 'The total volume of exceptional dispatch ...'; figures at Monthly_Report_files/figure-html/mma-ed*-1.png","example_result":"Exceptional dispatch volume: Jan 2026 156,062 MWh; Feb 2026 136,833; Aug 2026 45,706; Sep 2026 64,296. Feb 2026 shares: planned transmission outage 51.4%, unit testing 21.2%, voltage support 26.4%.","steps":["Open the month's market-manual-adjustment page for totals in the text.","Open the figure PNGs for daily values by reason and instruction type (no table or CSV)."],"reading_traps":["Exceptional dispatch is operator out-of-market dispatch, not a general redispatch statistic.","Daily splits exist only as images.","The Feb 2026 reason shares in the text add to 99.0%, with different labels from the Sep 2026 chart legend."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"page_only","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/html","size_bytes":26547,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Only text and one PNG (Sep 2026 figure by reason) were read; figure 10.2 values (incremental/decremental) were not read."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Economic and self-schedule curtailment definitions.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/feb-2026/renewable-resource.html","quote":"Economic curtailment is defined as the resource’s dispatch upper limit minus its RTD schedule when the resource has an economic bid."},{"claim":"Self-schedule and exceptional dispatch curtailment definitions.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/feb-2026/renewable-resource.html","quote":"Self-schedule curtailment is defined as the resource’s self-schedule minus its RTD schedule when RTD schedule is smaller than self-schedule."},{"claim":"Exceptional dispatch volume stated in MWh.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/content/monthly-market-performance/feb-2026/market-manual-adjustment.html","quote":"The total volume of exceptional dispatch decreased from 156,062 MWh in January 2026 to 136,833 MWh in February 2026."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"miso-monthly-operations-report","name":"MISO Monthly Operations Report (Daily Wind and Solar Energy and Curtailment)","publisher":"Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO), Market and Operations Analytics","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.misoenergy.org/markets-and-operations/real-time--market-data/market-reports/","data_url":"https://cdn.misoenergy.org/202509%20Market%20and%20Operation%20Report723860.pdf","access":"pdf","format":"PDF (60 pages; charts with printed values, no tables)","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","adds":"Second operator: daily average wind and solar curtailment in MW for the whole MISO system.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":4,"summary":"MISO's monthly operations report charts daily average wind and solar curtailment in MW for the whole system; September 2025 wind curtailment peaked at 1,281 MW on 09/08.","coverage_note":"System level, daily average MW, one issue opened (September 2025).","data_date":"2025-09","caveats":["Chart labels only; no table or machine-readable file.","MW average, not MWh; no node or zone."],"coverage":{"geographic":"MISO system level."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Daily average curtailment in MW (not MWh).","quote":"Daily Average Wind Energy and Curtailment","url":"https://cdn.misoenergy.org/202509%20Market%20and%20Operation%20Report723860.pdf","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://cdn.misoenergy.org/202509%20Market%20and%20Operation%20Report723860.pdf","note":"No definition of curtailment found in the report pages read (contents, wind and solar curtailment pages)."}]},"reference_date":{"value":"September 2025 report (daily values 09/01-09/30).","quote":"MISO Monthly Operations Report September 2025","url":"https://cdn.misoenergy.org/202509%20Market%20and%20Operation%20Report723860.pdf","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://cdn.misoenergy.org/202509%20Market%20and%20Operation%20Report723860.pdf","note":"Monthly report; the latest issue was not located because file names carry an opaque suffix."}]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"Daily Wind Generation and Curtailment (page 39)","meaning":"Bars of daily average wind energy (MW) and wind curtailment (MW)."},{"field":"Daily Solar Generation and Curtailment (page 43)","meaning":"Bars of daily average solar energy and solar curtailment (MW)."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -L -o miso_sep2025.pdf 'https://cdn.misoenergy.org/202509%20Market%20and%20Operation%20Report723860.pdf'  # pages 39 and 43; the text layer has no values, render pages to images","example_result":"Sep 2025 daily average wind curtailment: 1,210 MW on 09/04 and 1,281 MW on 09/08; solar curtailment peaked at 204 MW on 09/05.","steps":["Open the monthly report PDF and go to pages 39 (wind) and 43 (solar).","Read bar labels; no data table is provided."],"reading_traps":["Daily average MW, not energy.","Values exist only as chart labels.","Earlier or later months need their own PDF; file names are not predictable."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":3349066,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Only the September 2025 issue was opened; the text layer contains no curtailment numbers (values read from rendered pages)."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Report contents list curtailment charts.","url":"https://cdn.misoenergy.org/202509%20Market%20and%20Operation%20Report723860.pdf","quote":"Daily Wind Generation and Curtailment 39 ... Daily Solar Generation and Curtailment 43"}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"ercot-imm-state-of-the-market-2025","name":"2025 State of the Market Report for the ERCOT Electricity Markets (wind and solar curtailment)","publisher":"Potomac Economics, Independent Market Monitor for ERCOT","official":false,"landing_url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/","data_url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","access":"pdf","format":"PDF (175 pages)","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","adds":"Annual share of wind and solar generation curtailed due to congestion in ERCOT (percentages and charts).","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":5,"summary":"ERCOT's independent market monitor reports that about 4.7% of wind and about 6% of solar generation was curtailed (congestion) in ERCOT in 2025.","coverage_note":"Annual percentages for ERCOT as a whole; no MWh table, node or zone values in the text.","data_date":"2025","caveats":["Percentages only; chart values not extracted.","Published by the market monitor, not by ERCOT."],"coverage":{"geographic":"ERCOT; the report mentions load zones but the curtailment figures read are ERCOT-wide."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Share of generation curtailed (percent) with charts of production and curtailment 2021-2025; the MWh behind the charts are not given in text.","quote":"Roughly 4.7% of wind generation was curtailed in 2025, consistent with the trend over the last five years.","url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Curtailment due to congestion.","quote":"They also show the total amount of wind and solar curtailment due to congestion","url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Calendar year 2025; report dated May 2026.","quote":"May 2026","url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Annual.","quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","note":"Figure text could not be read (garbled glyphs); values of Figures 13 and 14 not extracted."}]}},"key_fields":[],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -L -o ercot_som_2025.pdf https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf  # section D 'Wind and Solar Generation in ERCOT'","example_result":"Roughly 4.7% of wind generation and roughly 6% of solar generation were curtailed in ERCOT in 2025.","steps":["Read section 'Production and Curtailment' and Figures 13 and 14."],"reading_traps":["Percentages, annual, ERCOT-wide; not MWh and not by node.","The executive summary says '6% of total generation' for solar while section D says solar generation: use section D."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":9250005,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Chart values are not machine-readable; only percentages in the text were read."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Wind curtailment share.","url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","quote":"Roughly 4.7% of wind generation was curtailed in 2025, consistent with the trend over the last five years."},{"claim":"Solar curtailment share.","url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","quote":"Roughly 6% of solar generation was curtailed in 2025, similar to 2024 levels."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"caiso-production-curtailments-xlsx","name":"Production and Curtailments Data - June-December 2025 (five-minute curtailment workbook)","publisher":"California ISO (CAISO)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/production-curtailments-data","data_url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/production-and-curtailments-data-june-december-2025.xlsx","access":"direct_download","format":"Excel (.xlsx), sheet 'Curtailments' (Date as Excel serial, Hour, Interval, Wind Curtailment, Solar Curtailment, Reason)","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","adds":"Five-minute wind and solar curtailment in MW with reason (Local or System) for calendar 2025; reconciles with the monthly CSV.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":6,"summary":"","coverage_note":"","data_date":null,"caveats":[],"coverage":{"geographic":"CAISO system level."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"MW per five-minute interval; MWh = MW / 12.","quote":null,"url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/production-and-curtailments-data-june-december-2025.xlsx","attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/production-and-curtailments-data-june-december-2025.xlsx","note":"Unit not labelled in the sheet; MW inferred from values and reconciliation with the monthly CSV."}]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/production-curtailments-data","note":"Rows exist only for intervals with curtailment; the legacy PDFs filtered amounts below 1 MW, the workbook was not checked for that filter."}]},"reference_date":{"value":"Dates 2025-01-01 to 2025-12-31 in the sheet although the file name says June-December 2025; posted 02/13/2026.","quote":"Production and Curtailments Data - June-December 2025 2.43 MB Report 02/13/2026, 3:52 PM","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/production-curtailments-data","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Discontinued: one-time bulk upload.","quote":"Note: We are publishing this as a one time bulk upload. Please refer to the Daily Renewable Report in the future for 5 minute curtailment data.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/production-and-curtailments-data-june-december-2025.xlsx","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"Date / Hour / Interval","meaning":"Excel serial date, hour ending and five-minute interval number."},{"field":"Wind Curtailment / Solar Curtailment","meaning":"Curtailment per interval in MW."},{"field":"Reason","meaning":"Local (congestion) or System (oversupply) per the legacy report definitions."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -L -A 'client/1.0' -o pcd.xlsx https://www.caiso.com/documents/production-and-curtailments-data-june-december-2025.xlsx  # sheet 'Curtailments'; MWh = (wind + solar) / 12 per row","example_result":"59,432 rows with dates 2025-01-01..2025-12-31; Reason Local 47,077, System 12,355. First row: 2025-01-01 hour 11 interval 7, solar 5.3 MW, Local. Monthly MWh equals the monthly CSV for Jan-Oct 2025; June +0.9%, November -6.0%, December -2.9%.","steps":["Open the Curtailments sheet; convert the Excel serial date.","Sum MW/12 by month to get MWh."],"reading_traps":["File name says June-December 2025 but the sheet starts on 2025-01-01.","No type column (economic, self-schedule, exceptional)."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","size_bytes":2543639,"records_total":59432,"records_for_country":59432,"problems":["Differences for June, November and December 2025 against the monthly CSV were not explained."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Page states the end of the report.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/production-curtailments-data","quote":"As of 6/1/2025 the ISO is no longer publishing this report. Curtailment data can be found in the daily renewables reports ."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"caiso-daily-curtailment-pdfs","name":"Wind and Solar Real-Time Dispatch Curtailment Reports (daily PDFs, 2016 to 2025-05)","publisher":"California ISO (CAISO)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-reports","data_url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf","access":"pdf","format":"PDF with hourly tables (DATE, HOUR, CURT TYPE, REASON, FUEL TYPE, CURTAILED MWH, CURTAILED MW)","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":false,"location_precision":"none","adds":"Historical daily PDFs with definitions of curtailment categories, hourly rows and year-to-date totals; discontinued 2025-06-01.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":7,"summary":"","coverage_note":"","data_date":null,"caveats":[],"coverage":{"geographic":"CAISO system level."},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"MWh and MW per hour by curtailment type, reason and fuel.","quote":"Curtailment is defined as the difference between actual production and the forecast when actual production is less than the forecast.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Only wind and solar, which have a forecast; amounts under 1 MW filtered.","quote":"Amounts smaller than 1 MW are filtered out for simplicity.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Report day; the last PDF opened is May 29, 2025.","quote":"Wind and Solar Curtailment May 29, 2025","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Daily until 2025-05-31.","quote":"This report is produced daily to provide a detailed accounting of the wind and solar renewable generation that was curtailed and the reasons why","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf","note":"Preliminary data, per CAISO: 'This data is preliminary and subject to change without notice.'"}]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"CURT TYPE","meaning":"Economic, SelfSchCut or ExDispatch."},{"field":"REASON","meaning":"Local (congestion) or System (oversupply)."},{"field":"FUEL TYPE","meaning":"WIND or SOLR."}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -L -A 'client/1.0' -o may29.pdf https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf && pdftotext -layout may29.pdf -","example_result":"YTD at 5/29/2025: LocalEconomic 2,178,988 MWh, LocalSelfSchCut 1,280, SystemEconomic 550,976, TOTAL 2,731,245; first rows: 05/29 hour 1 Economic Local WIND 162 MWh, 183 MW.","steps":["Pick a day from the monthly library listings.","Convert the PDF to text and read the tables."],"reading_traps":["Curtailment here is measured against forecast; the later market reports use the dispatch upper limit.","The YTD total (2,731,245 MWh at 5/29) is within 0.4% of the monthly CSV Jan-May 2025 sum (2,741,670); the difference was not investigated."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":296335,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Only one PDF was read; the index page lists 3,261 documents."]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Definition of curtailment categories.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/documents/wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-report-may-29-2025.pdf","quote":"Economic - Local: Market dispatch of generators with economic bids to mitigate local congestion³."},{"claim":"Discontinuation.","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-wind-solar-real-time-dispatch-curtailment-reports","quote":"As of 06/01/2025 the ISO is no longer generating these reports."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"ercot-mis-sced-disclosure","name":"ERCOT 60-Day SCED Disclosure Reports (NP3-965-ER), base points and high sustained limits","publisher":"Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.ercot.com/mp/data-products/data-product-details?id=NP3-965-ER","data_url":null,"access":"web_viewer_only","format":"Unknown (not reached)","license":"Unknown","language":"English","has_coordinates":null,"location_precision":null,"adds":"Resource-level dispatch from which analysts infer curtailment by node or resource (per secondary sources).","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":8,"summary":"","coverage_note":"","data_date":null,"caveats":[],"coverage":{"geographic":"ERCOT"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"","example_result":"","steps":["Open in a browser; scripted requests received an Incapsula 403."],"reading_traps":["Not tested: nothing here is verified."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-20","method":"blocked","http_status":403,"content_type":"text/html","size_bytes":860,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Both the data-product page and the GetReports listing returned 'Request unsuccessful. Incapsula incident ID' (HTTP 403)."]},"evidence":[],"members":[],"members_summary":null}],"sector":{"regulator":{"name":null,"url":null},"operators":{"structure":"many","note":"Curtailment and redispatch are published, if at all, by each ISO/RTO (CAISO, ERCOT, MISO, SPP, PJM, NYISO, ISO-NE) in its own format; only CAISO, MISO and ERCOT were opened.","census_url":null},"publication_obligation":{"exists":"unknown","norm":null,"url":null,"what_must_be_published":null,"frequency":null},"consolidated_republication":{"found":"partial","note":"No national operator-independent series was found; EIA republishes CAISO's annual total in an article.","checked_pages":[{"organization":"California ISO","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/daily-renewable-reports","saw":"Daily renewable reports index (Nov 2026: 18 reports) and replacement note for the PDF series."},{"organization":"California ISO","url":"https://www.caiso.com/library/production-curtailments-data","saw":"Production and curtailments data listing, 11 documents, discontinued 2025-06-01."},{"organization":"Midcontinent ISO","url":"https://www.misoenergy.org/markets-and-operations/real-time--market-data/market-reports/","saw":"Market Reports navigator page; no curtailment dataset visible in static text."},{"organization":"Potomac Economics (ERCOT market monitor)","url":"https://www.potomaceconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/2025-State-of-the-Market-Report-for-ERCOT.pdf","saw":"2025 State of the Market report with curtailment percentages."},{"organization":"ERCOT","url":"https://www.ercot.com/mp/data-products/data-product-details?id=NP3-965-ER","saw":"403 Incapsula block."}]}},"national_registry":{"exists":"no_evidence_found","note":"No single national dataset of curtailment or redispatch volumes was found: each operator publishes separately. This covers CAISO, MISO, ERCOT and EIA pages only.","checked_pages":[{"organization":"U.S. Energy Information Administration","url":"https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=65364","saw":"Article on CAISO curtailments; cites CAISO as the data source."},{"organization":"California ISO","url":"https://www.caiso.com/about/our-business/managing-the-evolving-grid","saw":"Page linking curtailments-monthly.csv."},{"organization":"Midcontinent ISO","url":"https://www.misoenergy.org/markets-and-operations/real-time--market-data/market-reports/","saw":"Operator-level reports navigator."}]},"if_unstructured":{"summary":"MISO and CAISO market reports are PDF or HTML documents with chart values; no data tables are provided for MISO or for CAISO's exceptional-dispatch daily splits.","recipe":[],"where_published":[]},"related_not_answering":[{"name":"EIA Today in Energy: Solar and wind power curtailments are increasing in California","url":"https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=65364","why":"Secondary article built on CAISO data; used only to check the 2024 total."},{"name":"ERCOT combined wind and solar dashboard","url":"https://www.ercot.com/gridmktinfo/dashboards/combinedwindandsolar","why":"Appeared in search results only; not opened and not a curtailment dataset."}],"open_questions":[{"question":"Which ERCOT report gives curtailment volumes by resource or node, and is it reachable without a browser session?","starting_point":"ERCOT MIS pages returned 403 (Incapsula); a secondary source says curtailment is inferred from the 60-day SCED disclosure (base point versus HSL).","next_step":"Open NP3-965-ER in a browser, record report format and fields, then test a download."},{"question":"Does MISO publish curtailment volumes in a table, and what is the latest monthly report?","starting_point":"September 2025 operations report PDF with chart labels in MW; MISO's Market Reports navigator is a script-driven page.","next_step":"Open the navigator in a browser for the operations report archive and any curtailment data product."},{"question":"Do SPP, PJM, NYISO and ISO-NE publish curtailment or redispatch volumes?","starting_point":"No pages opened; a search snippet says ISO-NE curtailment is low and SPP has no dedicated report found.","next_step":"Open each operator's market reports page and search for curtailment, out-of-merit and exceptional dispatch."},{"question":"Do CAISO's definitions of curtailment (forecast-based versus dispatch-limit-based) explain the 2025 differences between the five-minute file and the monthly CSV (June +0.9%, November -6.0%, December -2.9%)?","starting_point":"Both sets come from CAISO; ratio 1.000 for January-October 2025.","next_step":"Ask CAISO Market Analysis, or compare the daily PDFs for June and November 2025."},{"question":"What does 'Operator Instruction' mean in the daily renewable report and how does it map to ExDispatch?","starting_point":"Legacy PDFs listed ExDispatch - Local and System; the new report lists Operator Instruction - Local and System.","next_step":"Look for CAISO documentation of the daily renewable report or contact MarketAnalysis (address shown on the report)."}],"history":[{"pass":1,"date":"2026-11-20","role":"research","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","rules_version":"2026-11-20-eeuu-electricidad","note":"First pass from scratch: CAISO files reconciled (daily report, monthly CSV, five-minute workbook, EIA); MISO and ERCOT each tested through one report; ERCOT MIS blocked.","headline":{"official_data":"partial","non_official_data":"not_tested","national_registry":"no_evidence_found"},"sources":{"total":8,"new":8,"dropped":0},"negatives":{"overturned":0,"confirmed":0},"effort":{"pages":null,"minutes":null}}],"local_terms":[{"term":"Exceptional dispatch (ExDispatch)","language":"en","meaning":"CAISO operator instruction outside the market solution, used for non-modeled constraints and reliability; the closest published analogue of redispatch."},{"term":"Local vs System (curtailment reason)","language":"en","meaning":"CAISO reasons: local congestion versus system-wide oversupply."},{"term":"VER","language":"en","meaning":"Variable energy resource (wind and solar)."},{"term":"SCED","language":"en","meaning":"ERCOT security-constrained economic dispatch, source of base points and limits."}],"provenance":{"pass_count":1,"models":["claude-sonnet-5-5"],"minutes_estimate":null,"pages_opened":null,"passes":[{"pass":1,"date":"2026-11-20","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5"}],"note":"Minutes are researcher estimates. Counts describe documented passes, not publication approval. Missing history or effort is not reconstructed."},"card_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/us/curtailment-and-redispatch.json","detail_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/us/curtailment-and-redispatch/detail.json","html_url":"https://georutter.org/us/curtailment-and-redispatch/","country_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/countries/us.json"}
