{"schema_version":"1.0","country":"us","country_name":"United States","topic":"electrical-substations","question":"Where can I get the locations of electrical substations in the United States (transmission and distribution), with voltage level and operator?","territory":"us","territory_level":"country","parent_url":null,"published_on":"2026-11-19","research_reviewed_on":"2026-11-15","access_checked_on":null,"answer":{"official_data":"partial","non_official_data":"partial","summary":"No open official U.S. national substation dataset exists: EIA and HIFLD explicitly state they do not publish substation locations, DHS HIFLD Open shut down in late 2025 (Data.gov lists it restricted public), and FERC Form 715 (>=100 kV) is withheld as CEII. Official public data is limited to scattered state/regional GIS layers (e.g., MassCZM) and utility distribution hosting-capacity portals across ~26 states + DC + PR. Best free structured options are Oregon State University's June 2022 HIFLD mirror (79,280 U.S. transmission points with MAX_VOLT but no operator) and OpenStreetMap via Geofabrik or TransmissionMap (31,156 CONUS-bbox points, 96.7% NA voltage, 38.2% operator).","main_caveats":["DHS HIFLD Open shut down in late 2025; Data.gov (c633a) marks Electric Substations 'restricted public', and neither HIFLD Next nor Source Cooperative includes substations.","OSU's live HIFLD mirror (79,280 US records) is frozen at max VAL_DATE 2022-06-03, has 48.9% UNKNOWN* placeholder names (38,744), no OPERATOR field, and incomplete <69 kV distribution.","OpenStreetMap via Geofabrik/TransmissionMap carries voltage (96.7% NA CSV) and operator (38.2% NA CSV, 69.0% RI PBF) with 2026 updates, but covers fewer total US sites (~31,156 CONUS bbox).","Utility distribution Hosting Capacity maps are fragmented across ~58 utilities/agencies in 26 states + DC + PR (May 2024 DOE count) with incompatible schemas and often polylines rather than points.","Official federal FERC Form 715 (>=100 kV) and DHS HIFLD Secure data require CEII NDA or federal authorization; commercial vendors (Rextag, MAPSearch, LandGate, Infrageomatics) are paid."],"confidence":"high","confidence_reason":"Verified statutory restrictions on eCFR, EIA FAQ #567, Data.gov metadata, HIFLD Next/Source Coop catalogs, and tested OSU FeatureServer, Geofabrik PBF (ogr2ogr), TransmissionMap packs, MassCZM, and NYSEG REST.","attributes":[{"attribute":"location","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s001","s002"],"note":"Coverage combines distinct components of the question; see the original detailed evidence and its geographic and technical limits.","gap":"not_checked","gap_note":"The original rows have different scopes. Their combination has not been established as complete; original rows are retained in internal curation."},{"attribute":"voltage","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s001"],"note":"OSU 2022 (rank 1) gives MAX_VOLT/MIN_VOLT on 75.8% of US rows; OSM NA CSV (rank 3) has voltage on 96.7% (97.7% in RI PBF).","gap":"not_published","gap_note":"19,177 of 79,280 US points in OSU 2022 HIFLD lack valid MAX_VOLT (<=0 or -999999); MassCZM regional layer omits voltage entirely."},{"attribute":"operator","covered":"partial","source_ids":["s002"],"note":"OSM (ranks 2-3) includes operator on 38.2% of NA CSV rows (69.0% in RI PBF); utility HC portals (rank 7) identify their OPCO.","gap":"not_published","gap_note":"DHS/OSU HIFLD Substations schema has zero OPERATOR or OWNER column nationwide; MassCZM also lacks operator."}]},"sources":[{"source_id":"s001","name":"Oregon Explorer (OSU) — Legacy HIFLD U.S. Electric Substations 2022 Mirror","publisher":"Oregon State University (mirroring DHS/ORNL/LANL/INL/NGA HIFLD Open dataset)","official":false,"landing_url":"https://www.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/5d1c27f29e1f48cb85b67de46236b032?f=json","data_url":"https://services1.arcgis.com/CD5mKowwN6nIaqd8/arcgis/rest/services/project_renewable_us_substations_2022/FeatureServer/10","access":"api","format":"ArcGIS REST GeoJSON/JSON","license":"None (Public Use) per ISO 19139 XML metadata (US federal public-domain origin, 17 U.S.C. § 105)","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"academic","adds":null,"first_seen_pass":1,"rank":1,"summary":"Oregon Explorer (OSU) — Legacy HIFLD U.S. Electric Substations 2022 Mirror","coverage_note":"United States (79,280 records across 50 states, DC, and territories) plus Canada (401) and Mexico (6)","data_date":"Maximum VAL_DATE and SOURCEDATE in USA features is 2022-06-03 (epoch 1654214400000); XML metadata dateStamp is 2020-06-23; OSU AGOL item modified June 2025","caveats":["Consult the main caveats and the complete reading traps and access evidence in the detail."],"coverage":{"geographic":"United States (79,280 records across 50 states, DC, and territories) plus Canada (401) and Mexico (6)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Point features representing electric substations, taps, dead ends, and risers (USA TYPE breakdown: SUBSTATION 56,689; TAP 21,111; DEAD END 749; RISER 507; NOT AVAILABLE 224); voltages in kilovolts (kV)","quote":"This feature class/shapefile represents electric power substations primarily associated with electric power transmission. In this layer, substations are considered facilities and equipment that switch, transform, or regulate electric power at voltages equal to, or greater than, 69 kilovolts.","url":"https://oe.oregonexplorer.info/externalcontent/metadata/Substations%20_2022.xml","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Transmission substations >= 69 kV primarily; < 69 kV substations included opportunistically where authoritative sources existed","quote":"Substations with a maximum operating voltage less than 69 kilovolts may be included, depending on the availability of authoritative sources, but coverage of these features should not be considered complete. The Substations feature class/shapefile includes taps, a location where power on a transmission line is tapped by another transmission line.","url":"https://oe.oregonexplorer.info/externalcontent/metadata/Substations%20_2022.xml","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Maximum VAL_DATE and SOURCEDATE in USA features is 2022-06-03 (epoch 1654214400000); XML metadata dateStamp is 2020-06-23; OSU AGOL item modified June 2025","quote":"2020-06-23","url":"https://oe.oregonexplorer.info/externalcontent/metadata/Substations%20_2022.xml","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Frozen historical snapshot; upstream DHS HIFLD Open portal shut down in late 2025 so no new public updates are ingested","quote":"Thanks to our partners at the Public Environmental Data Partners and Fulton Ring, the rescued HIFLD data has become part of HIFLD Next, a new platform for discovering and accessing the 400-plus infrastructure- and resilience-related data layers from the US Department of Homeland Security’s defunct HIFLD Open data portal.","url":"https://www.datarescueproject.org/hifld-next/","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Incomplete <69 kV distribution coverage (only 3,384 US points have 0 < MAX_VOLT < 69); no OPERATOR or OWNER column; 19,177 US points lack valid MAX_VOLT (<=0 or -999999); 38,744 US points have placeholder NAME 'UNKNOWN*'","quote":"Substations with a maximum operating voltage less than 69 kilovolts may be included, depending on the availability of authoritative sources, but coverage of these features should not be considered complete.","url":"https://oe.oregonexplorer.info/externalcontent/metadata/Substations%20_2022.xml","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"ID","meaning":"Stable HIFLD substation identifier string (e.g. '107655')"},{"field":"NAME","meaning":"Substation name; 38,744 of 79,280 USA rows carry placeholder 'UNKNOWN*'"},{"field":"TYPE","meaning":"Facility role: SUBSTATION, TAP, DEAD END, RISER, or NOT AVAILABLE"},{"field":"STATUS","meaning":"Operational state: IN SERVICE, NOT AVAILABLE, UNDER CONSTRUCTION, INACTIVE, PROPOSED"},{"field":"MAX_VOLT","meaning":"Highest operating voltage in kV (-999999 or <=0 on 19,177 USA records)"},{"field":"MIN_VOLT","meaning":"Lowest operating voltage in kV"},{"field":"STATE","meaning":"2-letter US state/territory code"},{"field":"COUNTRY","meaning":"ISO-3 country code ('USA', 'CAN', 'MEX')"},{"field":"SOURCE","meaning":"Upstream state/EIA/imagery reference string; no OPERATOR or OWNER field"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL -o osu_usa_p1.geojson 'https://services1.arcgis.com/CD5mKowwN6nIaqd8/arcgis/rest/services/project_renewable_us_substations_2022/FeatureServer/10/query?where=COUNTRY%3D%27USA%27&outFields=*&resultOffset=0&resultRecordCount=100&f=geojson'","example_result":"{\"type\": \"Feature\", \"id\": 1, \"geometry\": {\"type\": \"Point\", \"coordinates\": [-91.864744367317, 45.7684233624903]}, \"properties\": {\"ID\": \"107655\", \"NAME\": \"UNKNOWN107655\", \"CITY\": \"SHELL LAKE\", \"STATE\": \"WI\", \"ZIP\": \"54871\", \"TYPE\": \"SUBSTATION\", \"STATUS\": \"IN SERVICE\", \"COUNTY\": \"WASHBURN\", \"COUNTYFIPS\": \"55129\", \"COUNTRY\": \"USA\", \"LATITUDE\": 45.76842336200008, \"LONGITUDE\": -91.86474436699996, \"NAICS_CODE\": \"221121\", \"NAICS_DESC\": \"ELECTRIC BULK POWER TRANSMISSION AND CONTROL\", \"SOURCE\": \"http://psc.wi.gov/utilityinfo/maps/electricmaps.htm\", \"VAL_METHOD\": \"IMAGERY\", \"MAX_VOLT\": 161, \"MIN_VOLT\": 69, \"MAX_INFER\": \"N\", \"MIN_INFER\": \"Y\", \"SOURCEDATE\": 1396828800000, \"VAL_DATE\": 1440720000000, \"LINES\": 5, \"OBJECTID_1\": 1, \"OBJECTID\": 1}}","steps":["Paginate FeatureServer layer 10 with where=COUNTRY='USA', resultRecordCount=2000 (service maxRecordCount), and incrementing resultOffset by 2000 until 79,280 rows are retrieved.","Filter TYPE='SUBSTATION' (56,689 US rows) if transmission taps, risers, and dead ends should be excluded.","Recode MAX_VOLT/MIN_VOLT <= 0 or -999999 to NULL, and drop/flag 'UNKNOWN*' placeholder NAME strings.","To infer likely utility territory where OPERATOR is absent, spatially join against HIFLD Transmission Lines (OWNER) or Form EIA-861 service territory polygons."],"reading_traps":["Must filter where=COUNTRY='USA': unfiltered queries return 401 Canadian and 6 Mexican border-grid substations; verified min/max for COUNTRY='USA' spans lon -165.43..145.73, lat 13.29..70.32 (0 non-US anomalies; positive lon +144..+145.7 is Guam/Northern Mariana Islands).","21,111 US features have TYPE='TAP', not physical substation switchyards.","-999999 encodes missing MAX_VOLT/MIN_VOLT; computing averages without filtering corrupts voltage statistics.","38,744 US rows (48.9%) use placeholder NAME='UNKNOWN######'; no OPERATOR/OWNER column exists."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/geo+json","size_bytes":66781,"records_total":79687,"records_for_country":79280,"problems":["No OPERATOR or OWNER field in schema","48.9% (38,744/79,280) carry placeholder NAME='UNKNOWN*'; 24.2% (19,177/79,280) lack valid MAX_VOLT","Frozen at VAL_DATE 2022-06-03; hosted on an academic OSU mirror rather than federal domain"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Layer focuses on transmission substations >=69 kV, includes taps, and has incomplete <69 kV distribution coverage.","url":"https://oe.oregonexplorer.info/externalcontent/metadata/Substations%20_2022.xml","quote":"In this layer, substations are considered facilities and equipment that switch, transform, or regulate electric power at voltages equal to, or greater than, 69 kilovolts. Substations with a maximum operating voltage less than 69 kilovolts may be included, depending on the availability of authoritative sources, but coverage of these features should not be considered complete."},{"claim":"Public domain / public use release terms stated in Oregon Explorer metadata.","url":"https://oe.oregonexplorer.info/externalcontent/metadata/Substations%20_2022.xml","quote":"None (Public Use). Users are advised to read the data set's metadata thoroughly to understand appropriate use and data limitations."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s002","name":"OpenStreetMap via Geofabrik U.S. State Extracts & Ohsome API","publisher":"OpenStreetMap contributors / Geofabrik GmbH / HeiGIT Ohsome","official":false,"landing_url":"https://download.geofabrik.de/north-america/us.html","data_url":"https://download.geofabrik.de/north-america/us/rhode-island-latest.osm.pbf","access":"direct_download","format":"OSM PBF / GeoJSON","license":"ODbL 1.0","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"community","adds":"Provides current 2022-2026 edits, switchyard polygon footprints, explicit operator and operator:wikidata tags, and mapped <69 kV distribution/minor_distribution substations absent from HIFLD.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":2,"summary":"OpenStreetMap via Geofabrik U.S. State Extracts & Ohsome API","coverage_note":"United States (all 50 states + DC + PR via 55 Geofabrik sub-extracts; continuously updated)","data_date":"Daily Geofabrik PBF snapshots (tested 2026-11-15); Ohsome API indexed up to 2026-07-27T09:00Z","caveats":["Consult the main caveats and the complete reading traps and access evidence in the detail."],"coverage":{"geographic":"United States (all 50 states + DC + PR via 55 Geofabrik sub-extracts; continuously updated)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"OSM nodes, closed ways, and multipolygon relations tagged power=substation","quote":"power=substation","url":"https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Power_networks/United_States","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Crowdsourced visible substations and manually verified HIFLD-guided additions; blind automated HIFLD bulk imports are prohibited by OSM Wiki rules","quote":"As mentioned in other parts of this wiki page, data should be imported on statewide or on a county/citywide basis by local mappers or other mappers with the support of the local mapping community.","url":"https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/HIFLD","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Daily Geofabrik PBF snapshots (tested 2026-11-15); Ohsome API indexed up to 2026-07-27T09:00Z","quote":"Geofabrik daily extracts, as of the last pipeline run","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/osm-substations.md","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Daily snapshots on Geofabrik","quote":"Geofabrik daily extracts, as of the last pipeline run","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/osm-substations.md","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Completeness varies regionally; distribution substations and rural areas are under-mapped relative to transmission; default ogr2ogr osmconf outputs closed ways in 'lines' instead of 'multipolygons'","quote":"Please note that, in many countries, this is not a complete depiction of the electricity network, and these statistics should be used with caution.","url":"https://openinframap.org/stats","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"osm_id","meaning":"OpenStreetMap node/way/relation identifier"},{"field":"name","meaning":"Substation name when mapped"},{"field":"other_tags:power","meaning":"Tag 'substation'"},{"field":"other_tags:substation","meaning":"Role: transmission, distribution, minor_distribution, industrial, generation, switching, traction"},{"field":"other_tags:voltage","meaning":"Operating voltage(s) in volts (e.g. '23000;4160'), semicolon-delimited"},{"field":"other_tags:operator","meaning":"Operating utility name (e.g. 'Rhode Island Energy'); accompanied by operator:wikidata where tagged"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL -o rhode-island-latest.osm.pbf https://download.geofabrik.de/north-america/us/rhode-island-latest.osm.pbf && ogr2ogr -f GeoJSON ri_sub_lines.geojson rhode-island-latest.osm.pbf lines -where \"other_tags LIKE '%\\\"power\\\"=>\\\"substation\\\"%'\"","example_result":"{\"osm_id\": \"19352523\", \"name\": \"Auburn Substation\", \"other_tags\": \"\\\"frequency\\\"=>\\\"60\\\",\\\"location\\\"=>\\\"outdoor\\\",\\\"operator\\\"=>\\\"Rhode Island Energy\\\",\\\"operator:wikidata\\\"=>\\\"Q130232431\\\",\\\"power\\\"=>\\\"substation\\\",\\\"ref\\\"=>\\\"73\\\",\\\"substation\\\"=>\\\"minor_distribution\\\",\\\"voltage\\\"=>\\\"23000;4160\\\"\", \"first_coord\": [-71.4290344, 41.764127]}","steps":["Download target state .osm.pbf files from download.geofabrik.de/north-america/us.html (or use earth-osm CLI).","Extract power=substation from ALL three geometry layers: points, lines (closed ways), and multipolygons (or customize GDAL osmconf.ini closed_ways_are_polygons to include power=substation).","Convert closed ways to polygons/centroids, parse semicolon-delimited voltage strings (volts -> kV), and deduplicate across adjacent state boundary overlaps."],"reading_traps":["CRITICAL GDAL trap: default ogr2ogr puts 165 of 171 Rhode Island power=substation features into 'lines', only 6 into 'multipolygons', and 0 into 'points'—ignoring 'lines' drops 96% of RI substations.","Ohsome rectangular state bbox queries (e.g. RI bbox) overlap neighboring states (yielding 202 vs 171 inside the Geofabrik RI polygon).","Ohsome API timed out on large CONUS bounding boxes; Overpass default curl returns HTTP 406 Not Acceptable."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/octet-stream","size_bytes":52544585,"records_total":171,"records_for_country":171,"problems":["Requires extracting and merging points + lines + multipolygons across 55 state PBFs for full US coverage","Rhode Island test yielded 171 features (97.7% voltage, 69.0% operator; lon -71.832..-71.170, lat 41.175..42.011); Ohsome DE test yielded 236 (198 voltage, 180 operator)"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"OSM US power network coverage tracked via OpenInfraMap and OSM Wiki.","url":"https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Power_networks/United_States","quote":"United States has 16308 power plants totalling 1,312,987 MW and 1,189,755 km of power lines mapped on OpenStreetMap"},{"claim":"earth-osm automates Geofabrik PBF substation extraction without API rate limits.","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pypsa-meets-earth/earth-osm/main/README.md","quote":"earth-osm downloads, filters, cleans and exports infrastructure data from OpenStreetMap (OSM). It provides a Python API and a CLI interface to extract data for various infrastructure types, such as power lines, substations, and more."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s003","name":"TransmissionMap Open Data Packs — North America OSM & Filtered HIFLD Substations","publisher":"BenHutchinsWPP / TransmissionMap (wpptx.org)","official":false,"landing_url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/README.md","data_url":"https://data.wpptx.org/data/releases/osm-substations-points-na.zip","access":"direct_download","format":"CSV (ZIP) & GeoJSON.gz","license":"OSM packs ODbL 1.0; HIFLD pack Public Domain (17 U.S.C. § 105)","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"community","adds":"Turnkey pre-parsed single-file downloads normalizing OSM voltage_raw -> nominal_kv + operator + op_wikidata, alongside a filtered 56,363-row non-tap HIFLD GeoJSON tagged with BA, NERC, and EIA-861 retail territory IDs.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":3,"summary":"TransmissionMap Open Data Packs — North America OSM & Filtered HIFLD Substations","coverage_note":"North America OSM (33,930 rows; 31,156 in CONUS bbox) and US + territories HIFLD (56,363 non-tap points)","data_date":"OSM Geofabrik extract as of pipeline build; HIFLD FeatureServer ef04dc82 acquired 2026-05-28 (validation dates through June 2021)","caveats":["Consult the main caveats and the complete reading traps and access evidence in the detail."],"coverage":{"geographic":"North America OSM (33,930 rows; 31,156 in CONUS bbox) and US + territories HIFLD (56,363 non-tap points)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"OSM substation centroid points (CSV) and polygon footprints (GeoJSON/SHP); HIFLD non-tap points with numeric nominal_kv / max_kv in kilovolts","quote":"Selected: all power=substation features — node, polygon-centroid and relation centroids. The polygon layer carries the closed-way footprints.","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/osm-substations.md","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"OSM NA pack includes all mapped power=substation objects in North America Geofabrik extract; HIFLD pack strips TAP/DEADEND/RISER/numeric placeholder rows from Feb 2022 ef04dc82 FeatureServer","quote":"Row filter: TAP / DEADEND / RISER / pure-numeric placeholder names are stripped → ~55,000 output rows","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/hifld-substations.md","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"OSM Geofabrik extract as of pipeline build; HIFLD FeatureServer ef04dc82 acquired 2026-05-28 (validation dates through June 2021)","quote":"Acquired 2026-05-28","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/hifld-substations.md","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Periodic pipeline rebuilds by maintainer; HIFLD component is static","quote":"Geofabrik daily extracts, as of the last pipeline run","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/osm-substations.md","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"OSM NA CSV lacks a country column (mixes US, Canada, Mexico); HIFLD pack strips 21k+ taps and relies on older Feb 2022 ef04dc82 vintage rather than OSU June 2022","quote":"Validation dates run through June 2021.","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/hifld-substations.md","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"lat / lon","meaning":"WGS84 centroid coordinates in osm-substations-points-na.csv"},{"field":"osm_type / osm_id / fid","meaning":"OSM element type and stable ID"},{"field":"operator / op_wikidata","meaning":"Operating utility string (38.2% filled in NA CSV) and Wikidata QID"},{"field":"voltage_raw / nominal_kv","meaning":"Raw OSM voltages string and parsed numeric kV (96.7% filled in NA CSV)"},{"field":"sub_type","meaning":"OSM substation=* role (transmission, industrial, generation, switching, etc.; 12,641 blank)"},{"field":"hifld_id / max_kv / min_kv / kv_range","meaning":"HIFLD GeoJSON ID and voltages (74.0% max_kv filled)"},{"field":"states / counties / ba / nerc / retail","meaning":"Spatially joined US state, county FIPS, Balancing Authority, NERC region, and EIA-861 retail territory IDs in hifld_substations.geojson.gz"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL -o osm-substations-points-na.zip https://data.wpptx.org/data/releases/osm-substations-points-na.zip && curl -sL -o hifld_substations.geojson.gz https://data.wpptx.org/data/layers/hifld_substations.geojson.gz","example_result":"{\"osm_na_csv_row\": {\"lat\": \"40.679078\", \"lon\": \"-73.771006\", \"osm_type\": \"way\", \"osm_id\": \"294894218\", \"fid\": \"2948942182\", \"name\": \"\", \"operator\": \"Long Island Rail Road\", \"op_wikidata\": \"\", \"voltage_raw\": \"11\", \"nominal_kv\": \"11.0\", \"sub_type\": \"traction\", \"ref\": \"\"}, \"hifld_gz_feature\": {\"type\": \"Feature\", \"properties\": {\"hifld_id\": \"107655\", \"name\": \"\", \"max_kv\": \"161.0\", \"min_kv\": \"69.0\", \"kv_range\": \"100-200\", \"states\": \"|WI|\", \"counties\": \"|55129|\", \"ba\": \"|MISO|\", \"nerc\": \"|MRO|\", \"retail\": \"|1251|13780|5574|\"}, \"geometry\": {\"type\": \"Point\", \"coordinates\": [-91.864744, 45.768423]}}}","steps":["Download osm-substations-points-na.zip (816 KB) and/or osm-substations-polygons-na.zip (2.93 MB) plus hifld_substations.geojson.gz (1.29 MB).","Clip osm-substations-points-na.csv with US Census state boundaries (since Canada/Mexico rows share the NA CSV without a country column).","In hifld_substations.geojson.gz, inspect or filter out rows where states='|none|' (372 rows: mix of coastal/border US facilities like Harbor Beach MI and Canadian stations like Ingledow BC at 49.16N, -122.87W).","Spatial-deduplicate OSU/HIFLD against clipped OSM points (~100-300 m radius) to combine HIFLD transmission coverage with OSM operator tags and recent 2022-2026 additions."],"reading_traps":["hifld_substations.geojson.gz contains 372 rows with states='none'—our audit found both Canadian stations outside the US (e.g. Ingledow BC at [-122.874, 49.159]) and US coastal stations outside Census polygon boundaries (e.g. Harbor Beach MI, Craney Island VA), plus 24 valid Guam/MP points at positive longitudes (+144.68..+145.73).","The 'retail' field in hifld_substations.geojson.gz is a spatial polygon join to EIA-861 retail service territories, NOT a confirmed asset operator (multiple utility IDs like '|1251|13780|5574|' appear per substation).","osm-substations-points-na.csv lacks a country field; filtering naively by bounding box (24.4..49.4N, -125..-66.9W -> 31,156 rows) still captures southern Canadian cities."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"download","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/zip","size_bytes":816132,"records_total":33930,"records_for_country":31156,"problems":["OSM NA CSV mixes US/CA/MX without country column (31,156 in CONUS bbox); only 45 rows explicitly carry sub_type matching 'distrib', though many blank sub_types have 4-24 kV voltages","Companion hifld_substations.geojson.gz (1,287,679 B, 56,363 rows) includes 372 states='none' border/coastal rows"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"TransmissionMap documents combining OSM and HIFLD sources and offers downloadable packs.","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/README.md","quote":"The map draws transmission lines, substations, power plants, pipelines, renewable-resource rasters and land constraints, worldwide from OpenStreetMap and, for the United States, from public datasets such as HIFLD and EIA."},{"claim":"HIFLD Open portal closure date and mirror origin documented in TransmissionMap.","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenHutchinsWPP/TransmissionMap/main/docs/layers/hifld-substations.md","quote":"The HIFLD Open portal closed September 16, 2025. This layer is sourced from the live HIFLD FeatureServer, with the ArcGIS item metadata and ANL GEM as corroborating references."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s004","name":"DHS / CISA HIFLD Electric Substations (Restricted Public / HIFLD Secure)","publisher":"U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) / CISA / ORNL","official":true,"landing_url":"https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/electric-substations-c633a","data_url":null,"access":"request_form","format":"FGDB / FeatureServer (restricted)","license":"Restricted public / vetted government HIFLD Secure Data Use Agreement","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"national_government","adds":"Official post-2022 authoritative DHS/ORNL substation inventory gated behind HIFLD Secure / DHS GII authorization after HIFLD Open closure.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":4,"coverage":{"geographic":"United States (all states and territories)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[],"how_to_use":{"example_request":null,"example_result":null,"steps":["Public automated download is disabled on Data.gov (accessLevel 'restricted public') and HIFLD Open closed in late 2025.","Eligible federal, state, local, tribal, territorial, or vetted critical-infrastructure partners must apply for HIFLD Secure access via DHS Geospatial Management Office."],"reading_traps":["Even the legacy open HIFLD schema lacked OPERATOR/OWNER and incomplete <69 kV distribution coverage.","Neither HIFLD Next (PEDP) nor Source Cooperative archived the Electric Substations layer."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"page_only","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/html","size_bytes":125074,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Data.gov metadata marks accessLevel 'restricted public' with no downloadable resource URL","hifld-geoplatform.hub.arcgis.com is a blank shell; dhs.gov/gmo/hifld and hsdl.org/hifld/ return HTTP 403"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Data.gov catalog registers DHS HIFLD Electric Substations as restricted public.","url":"https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/electric-substations-c633a","quote":"Homeland Infrastructure Foundation-Level Data (HIFLD) geospatial data sets containing information on Electric Substations."},{"claim":"EIA FAQ #567 confirms neither EIA nor HIFLD publishes electric substation locations.","url":"https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=567&t=1","quote":"EIA and HIFLD do not publish the location of electric substations."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s005","name":"FERC Form No. 715 & Critical Energy/Electric Infrastructure Information (CEII)","publisher":"Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","data_url":null,"access":"request_form","format":"Power-flow cases / system diagrams / maps (CEII)","license":"CEII Non-Disclosure Agreement (18 CFR § 388.113)","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"regulator","adds":"Official annual statutory transmission planning filings (>= 100 kV integrated grids, including bus/substation topology, voltages, and utilities), accessible only under formal CEII NDA.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":5,"coverage":{"geographic":"United States integrated bulk transmission systems >= 100 kV"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Integrated (non-radial) transmission facilities and substations/buses >= 100 kV","quote":"Any transmitting utility, as defined in § 3(23) of the Federal Power Act, that operates integrated (that is, non-radial) transmission facilities at or above 100 kilovolts must complete FERC Form No. 715.","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Mandatory for all FPA § 3(23) transmitting utilities operating integrated facilities >= 100 kV","quote":"Any transmitting utility, as defined in § 3(23) of the Federal Power Act, that operates integrated (that is, non-radial) transmission facilities at or above 100 kilovolts must complete FERC Form No. 715.","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"Annual filing due on or before April 1","quote":"FERC Form No. 715 must be filed on or before each April 1.","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Annual","quote":"§ 141.300 FERC Form No. 715, Annual Transmission Planning and Evaluation Report.","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Omitted from public access as CEII; excludes radial distribution systems and lines < 100 kV","quote":"Procedures for obtaining access to Critical Energy Infrastructure Information (CEII) may be found at 18 CFR 388.113. Requests for access to CEII should be made to the Commission's CEII Coordinator.","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[],"how_to_use":{"example_request":null,"example_result":null,"steps":["Identify public Form 715 Part 1 filing notices in FERC eLibrary (elibrary.ferc.gov/eLibrary/search).","Submit a formal CEII request and signed NDA to the FERC CEII Coordinator under 18 CFR § 388.113 detailing legitimate need and identity verification."],"reading_traps":["ferc.gov/ and ferc.gov/ceii block non-browser HTTP clients with a 403 Cloudflare challenge; statutory rules are verifiable cleanly via ecfr.gov REST XML API (--compressed).","Even when approved under CEII, public redistribution is legally prohibited."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"page_only","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/xml","size_bytes":2584,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Public download blocked as CEII under 18 CFR § 141.300(d); ferc.gov/ceii returns HTTP 403 Cloudflare challenge to curl"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"18 CFR § 141.300 mandates Form 715 >=100 kV filings by April 1 and omits CEII from public access.","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","quote":"Any transmitting utility, as defined in § 3(23) of the Federal Power Act, that operates integrated (that is, non-radial) transmission facilities at or above 100 kilovolts must complete FERC Form No. 715."},{"claim":"18 CFR § 388.113 governs FERC Critical Energy/Electric Infrastructure Information access procedures.","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=388","quote":"This section governs the procedures for submitting, designating, handling, sharing, and disseminating Critical Energy/Electric Infrastructure Information (CEII) submitted to or generated by the Commission."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s006","name":"MassCZM / Northeast Ocean Data — New England Electrical Transmission Substations","publisher":"Massachusetts Office of Coastal Zone Management (MassCZM) / Northeast Regional Ocean Council","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/e8f662e3baa5424481fabea06c621cf3?f=json","data_url":"https://services1.arcgis.com/7iJyYTjCtKsZS1LR/arcgis/rest/services/New_England_Electrical_Transmission_Substations/FeatureServer/2","access":"api","format":"ArcGIS REST GeoJSON/JSON","license":"Public planning dataset ('as is' without warranties per AGOL licenseInfo)","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"regional_government","adds":"Provides an unauthenticated official regional government GIS point layer covering the 6 New England states.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":6,"coverage":{"geographic":"6 New England states (ME, NH, VT, MA, RI, CT)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"OBJECTID","meaning":"Object ID"},{"field":"name","meaning":"Substation name (e.g. 'Acushnet')"},{"field":"state","meaning":"Full US state name (e.g. 'Massachusetts')"},{"field":"description","meaning":"Feature description ('Substation')"},{"field":"status","meaning":"Operational status (e.g. 'In Service')"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL -o new_england_subs.geojson 'https://services1.arcgis.com/7iJyYTjCtKsZS1LR/arcgis/rest/services/New_England_Electrical_Transmission_Substations/FeatureServer/2/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=*&resultRecordCount=1&f=geojson'","example_result":"{\"type\": \"Feature\", \"id\": 1, \"geometry\": {\"type\": \"Point\", \"coordinates\": [-70.913821, 41.670901]}, \"properties\": {\"OBJECTID\": 1, \"name\": \"Acushnet\", \"state\": \"Massachusetts\", \"description\": \"Substation\", \"status\": \"In Service\"}}","steps":["Query FeatureServer layer 2 with f=geojson and outFields=* (526 total records fit in a single request).","Spatial-join against OSM or HIFLD if voltage and operator attributes are required."],"reading_traps":["Regional subset only (6 states) and item modified May 2023; lacks both voltage and operator fields."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/geo+json","size_bytes":240,"records_total":526,"records_for_country":526,"problems":["Covers only 6 New England states","No voltage level or operator attributes in schema"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"AGOL item provides public planning layer across New England without token gating.","url":"https://www.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/e8f662e3baa5424481fabea06c621cf3?f=json","quote":"FOR PLANNING PURPOSES, ONLY. Northeast Regional Ocean Council and NortheastOceanData.org make no warranties or representations whatsoever regarding the availability, quality, accuracy, content, completeness or suitability for the user's needs of such information."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s007","name":"Utility Distribution Hosting Capacity Portals (DOE Atlas & Tested Utilities)","publisher":"U.S. Department of Energy (index) / Individual regulated utilities","official":true,"landing_url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","data_url":"https://services.arcgis.com/c0HK6TaWF3mGiNhc/arcgis/rest/services/NY_HC_PV_SUBBANK/FeatureServer/0","access":"api","format":"ArcGIS REST JSON / Heterogeneous utility portals","license":"Utility-specific interconnection terms of use","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"operator","adds":"Provides operator-published distribution substation-bank/feeder identifiers, distribution voltages (e.g. 12,470 V), and operating company (OPCO) in territories with public hosting capacity mandates.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":7,"coverage":{"geographic":"Fragmented: 58 utilities and state agencies across 26 states, Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico (May 2024 DOE inventory)"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":"Varies by utility: distribution substation banks (SUBBANK), primary feeder polyline segments, or hexagonal grid cells","quote":"Electric utilities working to expand their capacity to meet America's future energy needs use hosting capacity maps to provide an overview of a distribution system's ability to host additional electrical capacity","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":"Only utilities publishing voluntary or state-PUC-mandated hosting capacity maps","quote":"As of May 2024, 58 utilities and state agencies have published maps in 26 states, Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico.","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":"DOE directory updated January 26, 2026 (map inventory as of May 2024); NYSEG/RG&E subbank SDGDATE up to 04/30/2026","quote":"This was last updated January 26, 2026.","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":"Varies by individual utility; DOE does not maintain the maps","quote":"Note: DOE aggregated this list of publicly available maps for informational purposes only. DOE does not maintain the maps.","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":"Excludes ~24 states without mapped utilities, thousands of unmapped co-ops/municipals, and omits substation points in grid-cell portals like Ameren IL","quote":"Shading means that at least one utility within the state has a public hosting capacity map, as noted in Table 2, but does not necessarily reflect full state coverage.","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"SUBBANK","meaning":"NYSEG/RG&E substation bank code (NY_HC_PV_SUBBANK)"},{"field":"SUBSTATION","meaning":"Utility substation numeric/text ID"},{"field":"OPCO","meaning":"Operating company (e.g. 'RGE', 'NYSEG')"},{"field":"VOLTAGE","meaning":"Nominal feeder voltage in volts (e.g. 12470 in NY_Nodal_HC_Sup_HFS)"},{"field":"Name","meaning":"Substation/circuit area name (e.g. 'AUBURN')"},{"field":"SDGDATE","meaning":"Distributed generation hosting capacity update date ('04/30/2026')"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":"curl -sL -o nyseg_subbank.geojson 'https://services.arcgis.com/c0HK6TaWF3mGiNhc/arcgis/rest/services/NY_HC_PV_SUBBANK/FeatureServer/0/query?where=OPCO+IS+NOT+NULL&outFields=OBJECTID,SUBBANK,SUBSTATION,OPCO,SDGDATE&resultRecordCount=1&f=geojson'","example_result":"{\"OBJECTID\": 3, \"SUBBANK\": \"0001RO00T2\", \"SUBSTATION\": \"1\", \"SBANKPEAK\": 11.04577297, \"SBANKTC\": 9.375, \"OPCO\": \"RGE\", \"SDGDATE\": \"04/30/2026\"}","steps":["Look up target state utilities in DOE's Hosting Capacity Atlas table.","Inspect each utility portal's ArcGIS WebApp/Experience item JSON (when hosted on ArcGIS Online) to discover underlying FeatureServer layers.","Aggregate or derive substation centroids from feeder/subbank polyline convergence where standalone substation points are not published."],"reading_traps":["NYSEG/RG&E NY_HC_PV_SUBBANK (828 records) and NY_Nodal_HC_Sup_HFS (145,020 records) are polylines referencing substations, not point locations of substations.","OPCO is NULL on placeholder rows like SUBBANK='0001RO-None'; filter OPCO IS NOT NULL when attributing operating company.","Many portals in DOE's list (e.g. Ameren IL) omit substation identifiers completely or sit inside SPAs (Pepco, SCE DRPEP)."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"api_query","http_status":200,"content_type":"application/json","size_bytes":1500,"records_total":828,"records_for_country":828,"problems":["Fragmented across ~58 utilities/agencies in 26 states + DC + PR with incompatible schemas","NYSEG/RG&E exposes polylines (plus 145,020 feeder lines in layer 2) rather than substation points; Ameren IL exposes capacity grid cells only"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"DOE tracks 58 utilities and state agencies publishing distribution hosting capacity maps.","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","quote":"As of May 2024, 58 utilities and state agencies have published maps in 26 states, Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico."},{"claim":"DOE acts purely as an informational index without maintaining utility datasets.","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","quote":"Note: DOE aggregated this list of publicly available maps for informational purposes only. DOE does not maintain the maps."}],"members":[{"name":"NYSEG & RG&E (Avangrid) — Substation Bank & Nodal Hosting Capacity","landing_url":"https://iusamsda.maps.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/57b2a7548dde45819c9387bd1af521fb/data?f=json","data_url":"https://services.arcgis.com/c0HK6TaWF3mGiNhc/arcgis/rest/services/NY_HC_PV_SUBBANK/FeatureServer/0","access":"api","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"Exposed 828 subbank polylines (SUBBANK, SUBSTATION, OPCO='RGE', SDGDATE='04/30/2026') + 145,020 feeder segments in NY_Nodal_HC_Sup_HFS/FeatureServer/2 (VOLTAGE=12470, SUBSTATION, Name)."},{"name":"Ameren Illinois — EV Load Capacity Hosting Map","landing_url":"https://www.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/c1be35bccc1f4ae9a8af5a1e2a69c268/data?f=json","data_url":"https://services5.arcgis.com/3jEEGnl6c1x9Sze7/arcgis/rest/services/AIC_LC_Grids/FeatureServer/0","access":"api","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"WebMap 7c7b739727fb469fa3d57b5211a53933 exposes AIC_LC_Grids capacity grid cells and EV corridors rather than substation points."},{"name":"Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) — Distributed Resource Planning Data & Maps","landing_url":"https://www.pge.com/en/about/doing-business-with-pge/interconnections/distributed-resource-planning-data-and-maps.html","data_url":null,"access":"web_viewer_only","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"HTML portal page HTTP 200 without direct embedded FeatureServer REST endpoint."},{"name":"Pepco (Exelon) — Hosting Capacity Map","landing_url":"https://www.pepco.com/smart-energy/my-green-power-connection/developers-contractors/technical-consideration/hosting-capacity-map","data_url":null,"access":"web_viewer_only","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"HTTP 200 JavaScript SPA shell (2,963 B) requiring interactive browser session."},{"name":"Southern California Edison (SCE) — DRPEP","landing_url":"https://ltmdrpep.sce.com/drpep/","data_url":null,"access":"web_viewer_only","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"HTTP 200 JavaScript SPA shell (4,683 B) without direct REST endpoint in static HTML."},{"name":"Xcel Energy — Hosting Capacity Map","landing_url":"https://co.my.xcelenergy.com/s/renewable/developers/interconnection/hosting-capacity-map","data_url":null,"access":"web_viewer_only","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"HTTP 200 Salesforce/Experience Builder page linking to xeago.maps.arcgis.com ArcGIS Experience."}],"members_summary":{"total":null,"listed":6,"tested":6,"data_found":0,"scope_note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null},"member_scope":{"total":null,"note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null}},{"source_id":"s008","name":"Infrageomatics — OpenStreetMap Infrastructure Data Exports","publisher":"Infrageomatics","official":false,"landing_url":"https://www.infrageomatics.com/products/osm-export","data_url":null,"access":"paid","format":"GeoPackage / Shapefile","license":"OpenStreetMap ODbL 1.0 data packaged commercially","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"commercial","adds":"Commercial turnkey GeoPackage/Shapefile exports of OpenInfraMap/OSM power_substation point and polygon layers with parsed max_voltage, substation_type, operator, and wd_operator.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":8,"coverage":{"geographic":"United States (selectable country export) and global"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[{"field":"id","meaning":"OSM object ID (documented in Infrageomatics schema)"},{"field":"substation_type","meaning":"Derived from OSM substation=* tag"},{"field":"operator / wd_operator","meaning":"OSM operator and operator:wikidata"},{"field":"voltages / max_voltage","meaning":"OSM voltage(s) and maximum voltage in volts"}],"how_to_use":{"example_request":null,"example_result":null,"steps":["Select United States on infrageomatics.com/products/osm-export and order by card or bank transfer (schema documented at /products/osm-export/documentation).","Inspect free Luxembourg sample before purchase, or extract equivalent raw OSM ODbL data for free via Geofabrik (rank 2)."],"reading_traps":["Underlying completeness is identical to OpenStreetMap (rank 2); separates point and polygon features into _point and _polygon layers requiring centroid computation to unify."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"page_only","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/html","size_bytes":32566,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Paid commercial product for US extract (free samples cover only Luxembourg); /pricing returned HTTP 404"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"Provides paid GeoPackage/Shapefile snapshots matching Open Infrastructure Map.","url":"https://www.infrageomatics.com/products/osm-export","quote":"Infrastructure data from OpenStreetMap, cleaned up and made available in GeoPackage or Shapefile format for easy use in GIS software such as QGIS or ArcGIS. These exports provide a realtime snapshot of all electricity, telecoms, water, oil, and gas objects visible on Open Infrastructure Map."},{"claim":"Exports remain licensed under OSM ODbL 1.0.","url":"https://www.infrageomatics.com/products/osm-export","quote":"Data from OpenStreetMap is licensed under the Open Database License, and Infrageomatics does not claim any additional rights on the datasets we provide, so you can re-use and redistribute the data as you see fit, under the terms of the ODbL."}],"members":[],"members_summary":null},{"source_id":"s009","name":"Commercial U.S. Grid Intelligence Platforms (MAPSearch, Rextag, LandGate)","publisher":"MAPSearch / Rextag / LandGate","official":false,"landing_url":"https://www.mapsearch.com/","data_url":null,"access":"paid","format":"Licensed Shapefile / FGDB / Enterprise GIS API","license":"Proprietary commercial license","language":"en","has_coordinates":true,"location_precision":"exact","publisher_type":"commercial","adds":"Continuously updated proprietary North American/U.S. energy GIS datasets combining filings and aerial imagery with current substation locations, voltages, and owners/operators beyond the 2022 HIFLD freeze.","first_seen_pass":1,"rank":9,"coverage":{"geographic":"United States / North America"},"fine_print":{"unit":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"inclusion_rule":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"reference_date":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"update_frequency":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]},"exclusions":{"value":null,"quote":null,"url":null,"attempts":[]}},"key_fields":[],"how_to_use":{"example_request":null,"example_result":null,"steps":["Contact MAPSearch, Rextag, or LandGate sales for quote/enterprise GIS licensing when post-2022 authoritative operator and voltage attributes are required without federal CEII clearance."],"reading_traps":["Commercial subscriptions prohibit open redistribution; vendor public landing pages do not disclose record counts or distribution completeness rates."]},"test":{"tested_on":"2026-11-15","method":"page_only","http_status":200,"content_type":"text/html","size_bytes":72727,"records_total":null,"records_for_country":null,"problems":["Paid commercial quote required; S&P Global Commodity Insights returned HTTP 403 WAF"]},"evidence":[{"claim":"MAPSearch markets GIS asset data for the electric power sector.","url":"https://www.mapsearch.com/","quote":"MAPSearch offers superior GIS asset data for the energy industry–petroleum, natural gas, electric power, and renewable energy."},{"claim":"LandGate markets proprietary grid and infrastructure data solutions.","url":"https://www.landgate.com/","quote":"LandGate provides end-to-end proprietary data solutions for the top data center, energy & infrastructure developers and investors."}],"members":[{"name":"MAPSearch","landing_url":"https://www.mapsearch.com/","data_url":null,"access":"paid","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"HTTP 200 landing page advertising North American electric power generation/transmission GIS asset data."},{"name":"Rextag","landing_url":"https://rextag.com/","data_url":null,"access":"paid","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"HTTP 200 landing page offering North American energy infrastructure GIS data subscriptions."},{"name":"LandGate","landing_url":"https://www.landgate.com/","data_url":null,"access":"paid","tested":true,"data_found":null,"note":"HTTP 200 landing page offering grid/power pricing and infrastructure data for energy and data center developers."}],"members_summary":{"total":null,"listed":3,"tested":3,"data_found":0,"scope_note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null},"member_scope":{"total":null,"note":"Inherited members; data findings were not reclassified during this structural migration. Consult each member note.","pattern":null}}],"sector":{"regulator":{"name":"Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC), and ~50 state Public Utility/Service Commissions","url":"https://www.ferc.gov/ceii"},"operators":{"structure":"many","note":"Fragmented across hundreds/thousands of investor-owned utilities (IOUs), municipal utilities, rural electric cooperatives, and federal power marketing administrations; Form EIA-861 conducts a census of all U.S. electric utilities.","census_url":"https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia861/"},"publication_obligation":{"exists":"no_evidence_found","norm":"18 CFR § 141.300 (FERC Form No. 715) & 18 CFR § 388.113 (CEII)","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=141","what_must_be_published":"No federal obligation mandates public disclosure of substation locations; transmitting utilities >=100 kV must file Form 715 annually by April 1, but CEII is omitted from public copies under § 141.300(d). Some state PUCs mandate distribution hosting capacity portals.","frequency":"Annual regulatory filing (Form 715 by April 1); non-public CEII"},"consolidated_republication":{"found":"no_evidence_found","note":"No open official consolidated national registry exists; public users must rely on legacy 2022 HIFLD mirrors (academic/community), OpenStreetMap, fragmented state/utility portals, or paid commercial datasets.","checked_pages":[{"organization":"U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)","url":"https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=567&t=1","saw":"FAQ #567 explicitly states: 'EIA and HIFLD do not publish the location of electric substations.' EIA Energy Atlas DCAT-US catalog (101 datasets) contains zero substation datasets."},{"organization":"U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) / HIFLD & Data.gov","url":"https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/electric-substations-c633a","saw":"Data.gov entry lists accessLevel 'restricted public' (Dataset Last Updated September 11, 2023) with zero public download URLs; HIFLD Open closed late 2025 and dhs.gov/gmo/hifld returns HTTP 403."},{"organization":"U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)","url":"https://www.energy.gov/cmei/vehicles/us-atlas-electric-distribution-system-hosting-capacity-maps","saw":"DOE aggregates links to 58 public utility/state distribution hosting capacity maps across 26 states + DC + PR (May 2024), explicitly stating DOE does not maintain the maps or unify data."}]}},"national_registry":{"exists":"no_evidence_found","note":"No open public official national substation registry exists. EIA FAQ #567 confirms non-publication, DHS HIFLD Substations is marked 'restricted public' on Data.gov (HIFLD Open closed late 2025), FERC Form 715 (>=100 kV) is CEII-withheld under 18 CFR §§ 388.113 and 141.300, and HIFLD Next / Source Cooperative archives hold zero substation datasets.","checked_pages":[{"organization":"U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)","url":"https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=567&t=1","saw":"Confirmed non-publication ('EIA and HIFLD do not publish the location of electric substations'); Energy Atlas DCAT-US catalog (atlas.eia.gov/api/feed/dcat-us/1.1.json) contains 0 substation datasets among 101 entries."},{"organization":"Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) via eCFR","url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-18.xml?chapter=I&part=388","saw":"18 CFR §§ 388.113 and 141.300 mandate withholding CEII from Form 715 public filings and gating access via CEII Coordinator NDA; ferc.gov/ceii returned HTTP 403 Cloudflare challenge."},{"organization":"U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) / Data.gov","url":"https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/electric-substations-c633a","saw":"Metadata shows accessLevel 'restricted public' (updated 2023-09-11) with zero downloadable resources; hifld-geoplatform.hub.arcgis.com is a blank ArcGIS Hub shell and dhs.gov/gmo/hifld returns HTTP 403."},{"organization":"Public Environmental Data Partners (HIFLD Next) & Source Cooperative","url":"https://hifld.publicenvirodata.org/api/collections/hifld/datasets?search=substation","saw":"Confirmed total: 0 substation datasets in HIFLD Next STAC search and 0 substation folders among 302 prefixes in Source Cooperative seerai/hifld/ S3 listing."},{"organization":"North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC)","url":"https://www.nerc.com/","saw":"Publishes regional entity jurisdiction maps and reliability/CIP standards (e.g., CIP-014-4), not public substation coordinate datasets."}]},"if_unstructured":{"summary":null,"recipe":["1. Query the Federal Register API (/api/v1/documents.json) across rural-utilities-service, bonneville-power-administration, western-area-power-administration, and federal-energy-regulatory-commission for notices mentioning 'substation' and 'kV'.","2. Download the linked GovInfo Federal Register PDFs and referenced DOE/BLM EIS or FERC eLibrary non-CEII filings to extract substation names, operating utilities, kV ratings, and county/PLSS descriptions.","3. Resolve PLSS Township/Range/Section coordinates (for western public-land projects) against BLM National PLSS CadNSDI MapServer, and cross-link substation names with HIFLD Transmission Lines (SUB_1, SUB_2, OWNER, VOLTAGE).","4. Inspect USGS/USDA NAIP 0.6 m aerial orthoimagery (USGSNAIPImagery ImageServer) at candidate corridors/line junctions to verify exact substation switchyard coordinates."],"location_method":"Extract named substations, counties, or PLSS legal descriptions from Federal Register / NEPA ROD / FERC PDFs, trace connected line endpoints via HIFLD Transmission Lines (SUB_1/SUB_2), and pinpoint exact coordinates on USGS NAIP 0.6 m orthoimagery.","cross_with":["HIFLD Official U.S. Electric Power Transmission Lines (94,619 lines with OWNER, VOLTAGE, VOLT_CLASS, SUB_1, SUB_2): https://services2.arcgis.com/FiaPA4ga0iQKduv3/arcgis/rest/services/US_Electric_Power_Transmission_Lines/FeatureServer/0","Form EIA-861 Annual Electric Power Industry Report (census of all U.S. utilities to normalize operator names/IDs): https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia861/","BLM National PLSS CadNSDI MapServer (Township/Section geolocation for western federal/RUS/WAPA projects): https://gis.blm.gov/arcgis/rest/services/Cadastral/BLM_Natl_PLSS_CadNSDI/MapServer?f=json"],"where_published":[{"name":"Federal Register JSON API & GovInfo PDFs (USDA RUS, DOE/BPA/WAPA, FERC, BLM notices)","url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/api/v1/documents.json?conditions%5Bterm%5D=substation+kV&conditions%5Bagencies%5D%5B%5D=rural-utilities-service&per_page=2","what":"Official daily federal regulatory notices, EIS/EA Records of Decision, and interconnection/reliability orders naming operators, voltages, counties, and substations.","how_to_search_inside":"Query /api/v1/documents.json filtering conditions[term] (e.g. 'substation kV' or 'electrical substation') and conditions[agencies][] (e.g. federal-energy-regulatory-commission, rural-utilities-service, bonneville-power-administration), then fetch pdf_url from www.govinfo.gov.","example_document":{"url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2017-10-16/pdf/2017-22046.pdf","what_it_gives":"BPA/DOE Record of Decision (DOE/EIS-0505) identifying the 230 kV transmission project between PacifiCorp's Pomona Heights Substation (Yakima County, WA) and BPA's Vantage Substation (Grant County, WA), plus utility operators."}},{"name":"FERC eLibrary","url":"https://elibrary.ferc.gov/eLibrary/search","what":"Public FERC docket filings (interconnection agreements, certificate orders, non-CEII environmental assessments naming project substations and transmission utilities).","how_to_search_inside":"Search by docket number (found via Federal Register API, e.g. Docket #P-6619 or ER26-*) or text query ('substation') excluding CEII-designated attachments; cross-reference GovInfo Federal Register PDFs for published FERC notices.","example_document":{"url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2026-09-15/pdf/2026-18868.pdf","what_it_gives":"Federal Register Vol. 91 No. 177 containing FERC Order approving NERC CIP-014-4 (transmission substations) alongside PJM GIA/NSA interconnection docket filings (ER26-3745-000)."}},{"name":"U.S. EPA Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Database & DOE NEPA ROD/EIS Portals","url":"https://cdxnodengn.epa.gov/cdx-enepa-II/public/action/eis/search","what":"Federal EIS/ROD records for interstate transmission projects, federal Power Marketing Administration (BPA/WAPA) corridors, and USDA RUS cooperative grid builds.","how_to_search_inside":"Search EPA CDX EIS portal by keyword ('substation', 'transmission', 'kV') or agency, or browse DOE NEPA RODs (energy.gov/nepa/listings/records-decision-rod) and RUS notices via Federal Register API.","example_document":{"url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-06-30/pdf/2025-12026.pdf","what_it_gives":"USDA RUS Notice of Availability of ROD (Docket #RUS-25-ELECTRIC-0001) for Central Electric Power Cooperative's McClellanville 115 kV transmission project in Berkeley, Charleston, and Georgetown Counties, SC."}}]},"related_not_answering":[{"name":"HIFLD / DHS Official U.S. Electric Power Transmission Lines","url":"https://services2.arcgis.com/FiaPA4ga0iQKduv3/arcgis/rest/services/US_Electric_Power_Transmission_Lines/FeatureServer/0/query?where=1%3D1&returnCountOnly=true&f=json","why":"94,619 line geometries with OWNER, VOLTAGE, SUB_1, and SUB_2 text names, but does not provide substation point/polygon coordinates or distribution substations."},{"name":"Form EIA-860 — Annual Electric Generator Report","url":"https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia860/","why":"Covers generators >= 1 MW at electric power plants with coordinates and plant operators, not standalone transmission or distribution substations."},{"name":"Form EIA-861 — Annual Electric Power Industry Report","url":"https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia861/","why":"Census of all U.S. electric utilities (sales, revenue, reliability, service territories), not substation asset locations."},{"name":"Breakthrough Energy Sciences / PyPSA-USA U.S. Test System","url":"https://zenodo.org/api/records/4538590","why":"Synthetic grid model built for power-flow research rather than an inventory of real-world utility substations."}],"open_questions":["Which additional state GIS portals or state PUCs beyond New England (MassCZM) and the sampled NYSEG/RG&E hosting capacity API still expose active, unauthenticated distribution or transmission substation layers?","Across all 58 utilities/state agencies in DOE's May 2024 Hosting Capacity Atlas, how many beyond the 6 sampled utilities publish direct ArcGIS REST FeatureServers containing substation coordinates and voltage?","Does a full extraction merging points + closed-way lines + multipolygons across all 55 Geofabrik U.S. state PBF files yield significantly higher US distribution substation counts than TransmissionMap's 31,156 CONUS-bbox points CSV?"],"history":[{"pass":1,"date":"2026-11-15","role":"research","model":"Gemini 4 Hydrogen","rules_version":"6","note":"Initial research completed: confirmed no open official US national substation dataset (HIFLD restricted/closed; FERC Form 715 CEII); tested OSU 2022 HIFLD mirror, OSM/Geofabrik/TransmissionMap, MassCZM, and DOE utility HC portals.","headline":{"official_data":"partial","non_official_data":"partial","national_registry":"no_evidence_found"},"sources":{"total":9,"new":9,"dropped":0},"negatives":{"overturned":0,"confirmed":2},"effort":{"pages":90,"minutes":27}}],"local_terms":[{"term":"electric substation","language":"en","meaning":"Standard US federal/HIFLD/EIA term for facilities switching, transforming, or regulating grid voltage"},{"term":"transmission substation","language":"en","meaning":"Bulk-power substation generally operating at >= 69 kV (or >= 100 kV integrated grid under FERC Form 715)"},{"term":"distribution substation","language":"en","meaning":"Substation stepping voltage down to primary distribution feeders (commonly 4 kV to 34.5 kV / < 69 kV)"},{"term":"switching station","language":"en","meaning":"Substation that switches transmission lines at a single voltage without voltage-step transformers"},{"term":"substation bank (subbank)","language":"en","meaning":"Transformer bank inside a substation feeding distribution circuits (key unit in utility Hosting Capacity maps)"},{"term":"tap / dead end / riser","language":"en","meaning":"Non-switchyard line junction nodes bundled inside HIFLD's Substations layer (22,367 US rows)"},{"term":"CEII (Critical Energy/Electric Infrastructure Information)","language":"en","meaning":"Statutory category under 18 CFR § 388.113 used to withhold bulk grid locations and FERC Form 715 data"},{"term":"hosting capacity map","language":"en","meaning":"Utility map showing distribution grid capacity for DER/EV interconnection, often referencing substation IDs"}],"provenance":{"pass_count":1,"models":["Gemini 4 Hydrogen"],"minutes_estimate":27,"pages_opened":90,"passes":[{"pass":1,"date":"2026-11-15","model":"Gemini 4 Hydrogen"}],"note":"Minutes are researcher estimates. Counts describe documented passes, not publication approval. Missing history or effort is not reconstructed."},"card_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/us/electrical-substations.json","detail_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/us/electrical-substations/detail.json","html_url":"https://georutter.org/us/electrical-substations/","country_url":"https://georutter.org/v1/countries/us.json"}
